Review of I Am

I Am (III) (2010)
1/10
Woo Alert
29 June 2013
Warning: Spoilers
It started out OK just long enough to suck me in, then it went down the path of pseudo-scientific new age idiocy (aka woo) as bad or worse than "The Secret."

Real science is not going to lend legitimacy to your pet beliefs. Non scientists need to refrain from trying to make their unscientific beliefs sound scientific, because they always come off as naive, ignorant and stupid to anyone with more than a high-school understanding of science.

How do I know it's woo? Here are some selected quotes:

"Studies show that ..." Were these studies performed under controlled test conditions and were appropriate tests of significance used? They don't say, so the answer likely is "no."

"The science tells us that ..." No, it doesn't, unless you can show exactly how it does. Prefacing an unproven assertion with the word science only fools the naive and ignorant.

"Quantum entanglement ..." If you aren't showing me the math, you obviously do not understand quantum physics, stop bringing it up.

"The human heart can predict the future." Really? How exactly does the heart violate causality?
18 out of 32 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed