This is the first of only three films that Marilyn Miller made. Because she was the toast of Broadway, she didn't really need a Hollywood career and preferred the stage over films. Additionally, she had a drinking problem and died very young from the oddest of reasons....dying while undergoing surgery on her sinuses! So if you want to see her, this is one of your only chances.
When the film begins, Sally (Miller) is a poor working girl and isn't very good at her job in the cafe. She aspires to sing and dance on stage but has yet to be discovered. The film follows her from being a waitress to being a star...and all the problems in between.
Considering that it's based on the stage play "Sally" (also starring Miller) and it came out in 1929 (when sound technology was rather antiquated), the film is naturally incredibly stagy and the music is very old fashioned. While it played very well in the day, the music doesn't age all that well. It's made worse because late in the film it's one song after another after another...and they are quite tedious. Just a year or two later, sound films in Hollywood were a heck of a lot better and more timeless. Additionally, the film suffers a bit from being a black & white copy. Originally, it was filmed in Two-color Technicolor but only one brief musical sequence remains in color remains today...and it was only recently discovered.
As for Joe E. Brown, this film came out before he was an established star and it looks in this movie as if Warner Brothers really didn't know what to do with him. He's much more a supporting character and plays, oddly, a broke playboy and member of the royalty who's working incognito in the cafe!
Overall, this film is more of a curio...and oddity, as opposed to a film folks would want to see. Not a terrible film but a difficult one to love, that's for sure.
When the film begins, Sally (Miller) is a poor working girl and isn't very good at her job in the cafe. She aspires to sing and dance on stage but has yet to be discovered. The film follows her from being a waitress to being a star...and all the problems in between.
Considering that it's based on the stage play "Sally" (also starring Miller) and it came out in 1929 (when sound technology was rather antiquated), the film is naturally incredibly stagy and the music is very old fashioned. While it played very well in the day, the music doesn't age all that well. It's made worse because late in the film it's one song after another after another...and they are quite tedious. Just a year or two later, sound films in Hollywood were a heck of a lot better and more timeless. Additionally, the film suffers a bit from being a black & white copy. Originally, it was filmed in Two-color Technicolor but only one brief musical sequence remains in color remains today...and it was only recently discovered.
As for Joe E. Brown, this film came out before he was an established star and it looks in this movie as if Warner Brothers really didn't know what to do with him. He's much more a supporting character and plays, oddly, a broke playboy and member of the royalty who's working incognito in the cafe!
Overall, this film is more of a curio...and oddity, as opposed to a film folks would want to see. Not a terrible film but a difficult one to love, that's for sure.