Solid in many ways as a fun action oriented Star Trek movie. My biggest problem was with what I perceived to be a lack of credible motivation for the villain. Idris Elba is a presence on screen that typically commands my attention. He oftentimes brings a gravitas to roles that supersede the writing. But here, he struggles through a less than satisfying explanation for why he's doing what he's doing. Nevertheless, this doesn't altogether detract from a fun time.
Jaylah, played by Sofia Boutella (from Kingsman: Secret Service), was a welcome addition to the cast, yet peculiar in the sense she serves mainly to explain the rules of the narrative conflict and helps assist our protagonists through their struggle. But she was formidable as a strong female action star and I found her unique look to have a sexiness I didn't expect. Saying that, I was very happy they did not draw an obvious romantic involvement with any of our regular crew members.
Finally, I think it was interesting that the script included some real world connections. Nimoy's death was handled poignantly especially given that Yelchin also lost his life prior to this movie's premier. I even thought I noticed a subtle nod to this fact when the crew is toasting each other and those that had been lost, the camera quickly shows Yelchin's character, Chekov lifting his glass. Finally, Sulu's character is given depth when he greets his family on a space station. A real world connection to Takei (the original Sulu)? Perhaps it wasn't necessary to do this, but I value the effort to build character.
Overall, the story gave each crew member a vital role to play, satisfying one of the themes--"we are stronger in numbers when we work together". It was fun, fast, and (dare I add) furious in its action.
Worthy effort Grade B #recommend
Jaylah, played by Sofia Boutella (from Kingsman: Secret Service), was a welcome addition to the cast, yet peculiar in the sense she serves mainly to explain the rules of the narrative conflict and helps assist our protagonists through their struggle. But she was formidable as a strong female action star and I found her unique look to have a sexiness I didn't expect. Saying that, I was very happy they did not draw an obvious romantic involvement with any of our regular crew members.
Finally, I think it was interesting that the script included some real world connections. Nimoy's death was handled poignantly especially given that Yelchin also lost his life prior to this movie's premier. I even thought I noticed a subtle nod to this fact when the crew is toasting each other and those that had been lost, the camera quickly shows Yelchin's character, Chekov lifting his glass. Finally, Sulu's character is given depth when he greets his family on a space station. A real world connection to Takei (the original Sulu)? Perhaps it wasn't necessary to do this, but I value the effort to build character.
Overall, the story gave each crew member a vital role to play, satisfying one of the themes--"we are stronger in numbers when we work together". It was fun, fast, and (dare I add) furious in its action.
Worthy effort Grade B #recommend