Doris Day was really good in Hitchcock's remake of his own The Man Who Knew Too Much. But in Pillow Talk, I find her somehow completely devoid of any sexual appeal whatsoever. She moves stiffly, never ever seems less than uptight. I dare anyone to sit through her "crying" scene with the great Tony Randall and not be wishing he'd pushed her out of the car. As for Hudson -Rock is as bland as wonderbread. However Tony Randall steals the show. His blandness is out of the park stratospheric and makes for some genuine laughs !