I don't know if it is because I'm obsessed with horror movies and understood all the refrences in this episode but this was actually great. Sure, the stuff with Ursula and Eddie felt inconsistent and weird but I loved the tension it added to the episode. (and can I say how much Pacey has changed? I love it) And it's not like this episode is non-cannonical just because it's halloween themed, the plot continues progressing here. The ending was just icing on the cake. The reveal about the lady killer and the sweet moment between Dawson and Joey, I might start liking these series again.