Riding on Air (1937) Poster

(1937)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
It's Always Elmer
boblipton20 December 2018
Joe E. Brown is a small-town newspaperman with an assortment of hobbies, like ham radio and flying. He gets himself accepted as the local correspondent of a Chicago newspaper and is hoodwinked by Guy Kibbee as a successful investor, whom he brings back to town to organize a company for a local radio-controlled plane. Brown also has a girl -- Florence Rice -- and a theory he is pursuing for the paper about a man who was shot seven times and his bones broken.

It's an elaborately plotted comedy, done during the period when Brown left Warner Brothers for independent producer David Loew. While the story is nicely complicated, the gag structure, supervised by Eddie Sedgwick, is pretty tired. There's a thrill comedy sequence, but it's clearly shot on a set with a wing-walker doubling for a brief few seconds. Instead, the comedy depends on Brown's screen persona and big-mouth shtick. It is not, alas, enough to make this movie very funny.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
A Fair Flight for Joe E. Brown
wes-connors30 April 2011
Claremont, Wisconsin newspaperman and aviator Joe E. Brown (as Elmer Lane) wins the $5,000 first prize in a radio contest and is subsequently taken advantage of by sneaky Guy Kibbee (as J. Rutherford "Doc" Waddington). Then, the "Radio Beam Airplane Co." they form with the funds attracts a criminal element. Pretty girlfriend Florence Rice (as Betty Harrison) worries Mr. Brown may be in over his head. Taking his bath in this one, the popular comedian would have benefited from a wiser budget and some fresher material.

**** Riding on Air (6/18/37) Edward Sedgwick ~ Joe E. Brown, Guy Kibbee, Florence Rice, Vinton Hayworth
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Beware...the DVD print is crap-tastic.
planktonrules20 April 2010
Warning: Spoilers
Egad! Alpha Video once again has released a DVD with a practically unwatchable print! This super-cheap DVD production company specializes in public domain and other cheap to acquire films and they never, ever seem to do anything to clean up the prints. However, in this case, the sound quality is so horrid I was tempted to turn it off after the first few minutes--and the picture wasn't a lot better. In addition, while IMDb lists the running time at 70 minutes, this print was less than an hour! Some of this discrepancy can be explained because the film skips periodically and seems to have bits and pieces missing.

The only reason I didn't stop watching was because I was curious to see the sort of films that virtually killed Joe E. Brown's career. You see, after he left Warner Brothers (where he was a huge star), he signed on with a 'poverty row' studio (for David Loew Productions) that made some pretty bad films--or so I have heard. Just how bad this one? If you, too, are curious, keep reading...

Soon after the film begins, a local employee of a newspaper,'Elmer Lane (Brown), wins an essay contest for Krunchies Cereal that is announced on the radio. He's won $5000 (more than twice what an average worker made each year at that time) and Guy Kibbee convinces him to invest his money. You assume quickly Kibbee is a chiseler, as no reputable person would sign a hotel registry with 'Financier'! And, when Kibbee then tries to Kibbee sure looks like a crook....only Elmer is too gullible to notice.

Later, to clear his name, Elmer takes to the air (literally) and chases the crooks and becomes the hero. This flying sequence is handled pretty poorly--with the obvious use of a rear projected image of planes and Joe clearly NOT flying for real. While this is understandable, this is much poorer than what you'd normally see in films. Really.

Overall, the film isn't particularly funny and it's not up to the standards of his Warner Brothers films. While not terrible, it isn't all that good either--though some of this is due to the Alpha print and can't entirely be blamed on the production.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Joe E. is outgunned by a labored script and boring direction
JohnHowardReid25 February 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Never was a movie more accurately titled! The characters in this movie never seem to be riding on a decent script but on one they are making up themselves as they plow along. The main plot is as trite as they come, and if I ever I see another movie where the main subsidiary male is a confidence man, I'll scream! Why the hell couldn't they have a super-attractive woman playing the number one confidence sharpie/bungler once in a while? In my (admittedly brief) days as a detective – well I don't suppose 90 days is all that brief (I still remember just about every day most poignantly – thanks mostly to the two idiots who outranked me being also assigned to the investigation) – I came across no less than four very sharp and very attractive lasses in the confidence game. Anyway, Joe E. Brown doesn't seem to notice not only that the script's plot is as trite as they come, but that Guy Kibbee is hard at work upstaging him. Fortunately for Brown, Kibbee's material soon runs out of puff and he is forced to repeat himself so often, he becomes almost as boring as good old Joe E. Hard to believe this boring charade was directed by Edward Sedgwick who did such a marvelous job on The Cameraman (1928), Father Brown, Detective (1934), Air Raid Wardens (1943) and A Southern Yankee (1948), to mention just four of a dozen or more! Available on an excellent Alpha DVD which also features one of Brown's best films, When's Your Birthday?
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Not One of Brown's Best But Still Funny
jayraskin16 August 2012
I would agree that the movie is not well written or well directed. However, Joe E. Brown is still a great comedian. He offers a lot of clever twists and turns in the plot and makes the whole thing passable entertainment.

Brown belongs on the short list of great 1930's comedians with Laurel and hardy, W.C. Fields and Mae West. He is a wonderful combination of rube and conman. He has a wide mouth not matched in size till Jim Carrey in the 90's.

Even here, not generally his best material, there are many chuckles to be had. The short scene of him taking a bath is a little gem. He has all kinds of weird contraptions to make the bath process easier. Perhaps only Keaton could have done it better. Daredevil antics in an airplane remind one of Harold Lloyd. Except for Lloyd, nobody could have done it better.

There is a curious lack of music throughout this film. I am wondering if the music track was lost at some point. Anybody know about this?
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed