Monelle (1948) Poster

(1948)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Imaginez que vous êtes au cinéma.
ulicknormanowen28 March 2020
Warning: Spoilers
After the last pictures , a warning was issued on the screen :" don't let anybody out! ; if ,in those troubled times,you prefer a happy ending ,this is how it could have ended": so the wife forgives her husband, who,remembering the good times(the first marvelous sequences) ,falls in love with her again.This ending was filmed to be able to sell the movie abroad ,but neither director Decoin, nor writer Jeanson approve of it .Now the pessimistic denouement is generally screened.

Decoin's movies fall into two genres :the light witty comedy (such as "battements de coeur" ) and the film noir at its darkest("Non Coupable " "la fille du diable" ); "les amoureux sont seuls au monde " belongs to the latter category ,although it featured one of the happiest beginning Decoin had ever filmed : the meeting in the cafe , the wedding , the boy who sells good-luck charms (who ironically will get lucky himself ,his ludicrous shop being almost an insult to the composer's despair ;the ball at the wedding is one of these magnificent populist scenes only the great directors can achieve (Renoir,Duvivier,Becker): the "fancy for a dance grandma?"echoes to a similar scene in "La belle équipe" which incidentally features two endings too.

Perhaps more than Louis Jouvet,it's Renée Devillers who is the stand out; the lovers ,whatever their age may be ,are lonely in this cruel world where the gutter press cashes on the situation when a famous maestro has a young protegee (Dany Robin) play in his orchestra ; the gossips run rampant even before the concert makes the headlines : both Manelle's boyfriend (Philippe Lemaire ) and her friend (Brigitte Auber) exchange nasty lines when the musicians are playing,deaf to the music.

Maybe too slow-moving, the movie captivates ,because of this woman who lives every day to love her husband ,to make him happy ;nothing else fits in her plans ,so when she loses him ,she loses everything .

"Sylvia is still living in this imbecile's mind ", an idiot who epitomizes the whole world of the gossip press and their readers who destroyed all this happiness of a luminous day in a small inn in the forest.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Lonely are the lovers...
dbdumonteil21 January 2006
Warning: Spoilers
There are reportedly two endings,one featuring a happy one,like Duvivier's "La Belle Equipe" .I have seen the sad version.

Henry Decoin was mainly known for his films noirs."Les Amoureux sont seuls au Monde" rather belongs to the melodrama genre.A famous composer (Jouvet) helps a young piano virtuoso make a career.But he's getting old and the gutter press begins to write saucy lines about how the girl makes him feel younger ... and in love.Unfortunately he is married and he dearly loves his wife.

My favorite parts are the long prologue and the epilogue:they both take place in an inn and in a forest where Jouvet sings the old love folk song "A La Claire Fontaine" which goes on repeating "IL y a Longtemps Que Je T'aime "( = I've been loving you for so long).

Prologue:there's a wedding at the inn and they have no musician;so they ask the earnest composer to play popular tunes so the guests can dance.Then the musician and his wife take a walk in the forest where their love seems to be forever.

Epilogue:Jouvet comes back to the inn after the tragedy.He does not tell the owner about what happened because "in his mind she's still alive".Then he and his good friend go away in the forest..
16 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Into The Woods
writers_reign21 June 2006
Warning: Spoilers
For a man whose first love was the theatre - where he distinguished himself as both actor and director especially in the works of Jean Giradoux - and who only took on film roles to bankroll his theatre company Louis Jouvet appeared in some pretty classy movies not least Un Carnet du bal, La Kermesse Heroique, Drole de Drame, La Fin du jour, Quai des Orfevres not forgetting Hotel du Nord where he and Arletty, in what were intended as supporting roles, completely outclassed the nominal leads Anabella and Jean-Pierre Aumont. Jouvet appeared twice for director Henri Decoin, one of the best-kept secrets of French cinema who also had the great fortune to be married for six years (1935-41) to Danielle Darrieux, with whom he made the classic Battement de coeur, in Entre onze heures et minuit and this wonderful low-key entry a sort of Intermezzo with a French accent written by the great Henri Jeanson. Jouvet, who seemed to have been born middle-aged, plays a renowned composer deeply in love with his wife who 'discovers' a gifted young pianist and grooms her for the concert stage. In time the 'usual' rumors begin to circulate and his wife takes them seriously enough to make for a tragic ending. Decoin liked to shoot in the classical style; master-shot, medium shot, close shot, two-shot, three-shot, Reverse angle etc but he was also capable, as here, of fluid montage carried entirely by the voice-overs of Jouvet and his wife. There's a charming Prologue - and bittersweet Epilogue - set in an inn deep in the forest. In the Prologue, Jouvet, who is completely unknown to the guests at a local wedding, is prevailed upon to play 'pop' and folk tunes on the piano, after which a hat is passed round. The Prologue has overtones of 'enchanted' forest, the sort of place that Shakespeare liked to ship his characters to enjoy a break from the everyday world, a place, in fact, where a prestigious composer can play pub pianist and let his hair down for a magic moment or two. In the Epilogue however all bets are off and in a closing shot that echoes Casablanca, Jouvet and friend walk off into a forest no longer enchanted which swallows them up. Not a masterpiece but a charming forgotten gem.
13 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A la claire fontaine
dbdumonteil8 February 2019
There are reportedly two endings,one featuring a happy one,like Duvivier's "La Belle Equipe" .I have seen the sad version.

Henry Decoin was mainly known for his films noirs."Les Amoureux sont seuls au Monde" rather belongs to the melodrama genre.A famous composer (Jouvet) helps a young piano virtuoso make a career.But he's getting old and the gutter press begins to write saucy lines about how the girl makes him feel younger ... and in love.Unfortunately he is married and he dearly loves his wife.

My favorite parts are the long prologue and the epilogue:they both take place in an inn and in a forest where Jouvet sings the old love folk song "A La Claire Fontaine" which goes on repeating "IL y a Longtemps Que Je T'aime "( = I've been loving you for so long).

Prologue:there's a wedding at the inn and they have no musician;so they ask the earnest composer to play popular tunes so the guests can dance.Then the musician and his wife take a walk in the forest where their love seems to be forever.

Epilogue:Jouvet comes back to the inn after the tragedy.He does not tell the owner about what happened .Then he and his good friend go away in the forest..

Bertrand TAVERNIER used one of the lines of the dialog to open the ten episodes of his "voyage dans le cinema français" series
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed