One Meat Brawl (1947) User Reviews

Philologists have long wondered whether it would be easier for a human to . . .

[tadpole-596-918256 · 7/10 · 26 October 2020]

. . . converse with a dog, or if it would be more likely for a groundhog to get through to Rover. (After all, ground hog rhymes with hound dog, no matter what Elvis thought.) With Elmer Fudd gone totally AWOL during ONE MEAT BRAWL, perhaps it is impossible to solve this conundrum on the basis of this single animated short. (For those not paying close attention here, Porky is a member of the Pork family.) This parenthetical thought raises another objection to the scientific validity of ONE MEAT BRAWL, to whit: Who ever has heard of a mutt named Mandrake? Evidently Porky has, but that's got to be up a hog's alley. Pigs root out truffles--might they not save mandrakes for a rainy day?

Slow start and not much new in terms of story, but definitely worth watching

[TheLittleSongbird · 7/10 · 24 August 2012]

One Meat Brawl is not one of my favourites from Looney Tunes. It starts off slow, with a nice if going-on-for-slightly-too-long song from the Groundhog. The story is also not much new, reading a lot like the Bugs and Elmer cartoons, which worked even with this formula with stronger characters and somewhat wittier humour, but with Porky, Mandrake and the Groundhog. However, after Mandrake meets the Groundhog for the first time, One Meat Brawl picks up significantly and the rest is a lot of fun. The dialogue is suitably witty, I did get a good laugh out of the Groundhog's aside "dogs are suckers for sob stories", and the gags are great especially Porky and Mandrake wrestling with one another and the Groundhog joins in, the shadows fighting for nothing at the end and especially Porky's hilarious reaction at the Groundhog making a sap out of Mandrake(Porky too gets this later on). Porky is better when he is working with Daffy with equal screen time, but he isn't shoved into the background, and while his material is not as funny as Mandrake or the Groundhog he does have some very good moments. Mandrake is a strong character, whether he is chasing the Groundhog, manipulating Porky into that he ate him or when he is crying his eyes out. But the star of One Meat Brawl was the Groundhog, even with his cute appearance(which can go either way in cartoons) this is one funny character. I love his asides, which are almost worthy of Bugs and Daffy, while what he says as he makes a sap out of both Mandrake and Porky, sad as some of it is, is hysterically funny. Mel Blanc as ever gives bravura characterisations. The animation is colourful with really beautiful backgrounds especially with the very opening with the Vienesse-waltz-style music accompanying it. Porky is not as well drawn as he has been before, but is still acceptable regardless. The music is both lush in orchestration and energetic in pace, which is what one would expect. All in all, definitely worth the look. 7/10 Bethany Cox

Like Bugs cartoons but with different characters

[bob the moo · 15 November 2003]

It's Groundhog Day and Grover Groundhog is preparing in his home for his big appearance in front of the cameras. However when he emerges he is turned on by hunters due to the meat shortage. Porky Pig and his hound dog go out to hunt the groundhog down and cook him up. However the groundhog proves to be a more difficult (and manipulative) prey that they first thought.

A little slow to start, this cartoon soon becomes a little like the usual Bugs/Elmer cartoons but with the groundhog playing Bugs and Porky playing Elmer's character. Keeping the same sense of humour (e.g. the groundhog outsmarting the hunters) the cartoon works out pretty good and is quite funny at turns.

Porky is an OK character and the groundhog is a good despite being a little too cute for it's own good. The downside of this is that I couldn't help but compare him to Bugs, a comparison that will leave even a strong character standing in the shadows. Of the three, the dog is pretty good and he covers for the weaknesses in Porky.

Overall this is a good little short that takes the usual Bugs jokes and puts them onto new characters. Despite a little bit of a faltering start with the groundhog singing the short is a mix of witty game playing.

That's brawl, folks.

[lee_eisenberg · 7/10 · 19 March 2010]

While most Warner Bros. cartoons featured animals, I assume that Robert McKimson's "One Meat Brawl" marked the only appearance by a groundhog. In this case, Grover Groundhog has to leave his den to see whether or not he has a shadow, and the hunters are waiting for him, sending him into hiding. Meanwhile, Porky Pig and his dog Mandrake (Barnyard Dawg from the Foghorn Leghorn cartoons) are hunting groundhogs, but Grover knows how to get Mandrake on his side. Are hunts always doomed to go like this?! I guess that we could be cynical and say that this cartoon is no different from the average Bugs Bunny-Elmer Fudd cartoon, but I think that as long as cartoons make us laugh, they're good. I recommend this one. After all, who doesn't like hand shadows?

"Does my shadow mean Spring Time . . . "

[oscaralbert · 7/10 · 2 September 2015]

" . . . or 16 feet of snow?" croons Grover the Groundhog before facing a circular firing squad (due to America's national meat shortage immediately after WWII). Guns permeate ONE MEAT BRAWL. Grover even tries to commit suicide by squirt gun midway through this Warner Bros. animated short. And no wonder: The prolific mammal has 72 offspring and a wife hung up on wearing nylons, enough to drive any husband batty. Grover yearns to ditch the other 73 members of his family (not shown here) and play polo while smoking machine-made cigarettes. By the end of this story he decides that hanging out with the murderous duo of Porky Pig and Porky's hunting dog Mandrake is the next best thing to his nicotine-fueled polo dreams. After all, when one guy threatens to "put a couple slugs" in you, why NOT invite him into your secret bachelor pad? It's the American thing to do. (Dick Tracy's newspaper comic strip may have given rise to the Apple Watch, but Grover demonstrates a beta version of the Walkman here in ONE MEAT BRAWL).