Le mataf (1973) Poster

(1973)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
A bit dull but I am glad I watched it .....
PimpinAinttEasy15 June 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Dear Stelvio Cipriani,

your brilliant background score is the best part of this rather languid and unremarkable crime thriller. Stelvio, the romantic saxophone laced main theme was both melancholic and memorable. I have been playing it in my car for the last one year. The director Serge Leroy used it very well - especially in the romantic scenes.

Le Mataf begins in an interesting manner with a voice over introducing the three thieves. Michel Constantin, with his imposing presence and rather gruff voice might be the French Lee Marvin. Him and his two cohorts are the victims of a blackmail plot after they are photographed attempting to rob a train. The blackmailers force the trio to steal a roll of film (it is never revealed what the film contains) off a ship. Double crosses and triple crosses ensue. The flimsy plot is not even the film's major problem. The heist scene in the ship was supposed to be procedural like in a Melville or Verneuil film. But it was quite unimaginative and was the very opposite of thrilling. The action scenes were sleep inducing. No dialog stood out though the romantic scenes were quite interesting mainly due to your score, Stelvio.

What I liked about the film were the locales - especially the bars and the cafes. The pairing of the gigantic Michel Constantin with the petite Cathy Rosier suggests the director is indeed a man of taste. However, every scene makes you wish the director had hired a better scenarist. But he certainly hired the right composer. Your background score lent a melancholic and superior air to this otherwise dull film, Stelvio.

Best Regards, Pimpin.

(6/10)
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A simple story!
RodrigAndrisan6 November 2017
A Michel Constantin as we know him, tough and very natural. So Adolfo Celi, naturally, but less harsh and more sympathetic. The same, Georges Géret, as we know from all his movies, naturally too. Beautiful music signed by Stelvio Cipriani. It's not a masterpiece but, overall, this movie looks very realistic.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Average French Crime-Waster from the 1970s
mackjay219 September 2023
It might be difficult not to think of the films of Jean-Pierre Melville when watching LE MATAF. It covers similar ground to those of the great master, but it lacks Melville's talent for telling the story. Here, we have a fast-moving narrative, including a moment or two of confusion as to what exactly is happening. Unlike Melville, Serge Leroy doesn't take time to live with the characters, or to give scenes enough time to have full impact. Undoubtedly, there are some effective moments (as with the fate of a female character, late in the film) but too much feels perfunctory (the 'romance' between Constantin and Rozier). However, there are far worse examples in the huge crime film catalog of the 1970s.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Sail away sailor
dbdumonteil29 January 2013
Serge Leroy 's sophomore effort for the silver screen (the first one "Ciel Bleu" seems rather interesting but is nowhere to be found)has a strong male cast :Michel Constantin,was par excellence,the tough guy of the French B movies (but in his filmography one masterpiece :Jacques Becker's "Le Trou" (1959),the best French prison movie ever made ,and no ,it's not a Nouvelle Vague work!);Georges Géret ,Pierre Santini and Adolfo -"Thunderball"-Celi provide good support;unfortunately ,Cathy Rosier is as expressive as a Barbie doll and Annie Cordy's role is underwritten.

The story is complicated instead of complex :it involves secret microfilms ,frame-ups,corrupt lawyer and lots of dollars ,plus a song by Annie Cordy .But all in all ,it's just another thriller .Leroy's next movie "La Traque" will be simpler and much more absorbing .

The title: it's explained in the movie ;a "Mataf" is slang for "sailor" who joins the navy for five years ;the connection with the movie is thin,unless the hero's ship (in the last sequence) counts
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
a tale of gangsters pitted against other gangsters
myriamlenys13 October 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Some men have planned a robbery. It's supposed to be an elegant, well-organized affair without bloodshed. During the preparations phase something unexpected happens : a third party intervenes in order to kill one of the innocent bystanders. As a result that third party now has something to blackmail the men about, complete with crystal-clear photographs which show them crawling all over the neighbourhood...

"Le mataf" is a gangster movie about various groups of gangsters blackmailing, double-crossing and killing each other. The settings are interesting, the stuntwork is impressive and the performances are nicely natural and realistic. (Michel Constantin, in particular, is impressive.) There is also a beautifully melancholic musical score. The plot, however, is quite elaborate. Now there is nothing wrong with creating a complicated plot, on condition that the viewer can understand all that's happening. It is here that the storytelling falls short, especially in the beginning.

The movie begins with an enormously short and compressed introduction : in the space of only a few minutes, the viewer gets introduced to a band of criminals, to their criminal enterprise, to the failure of that criminal enterprise and to the interfering presence of an unknown, merciless third party with its own agenda. From a storytelling perspective it might have been wiser to devote more time and attention to this episode, especially since it lays the foundations for later developments.

While we're at it, there are a number of characters which remain a human mystery : basically, they're Gangster Number Five, Bodyguard Number Two or Henchman Number Four. A bit of fleshing out might have done wonders here.

Still, quite watchable for a rainy afternoon.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Taut crime movie
searchanddestroy-118 September 2022
And the first movie from director Serge Leroy, who will come back to a crime film only for L'INDIC, ten years later. This is not an ambitious film but powerfully done, with conviction. It is rough, accurate in story telling and editing. I don't even speak of the acting. It is a French crime movie that can't be missed by those who like this genre. Cathy Rosier has not really hr place, unlike in LE SAMOURAI, six years earlier. Michel Constantin is as awesome as usual and Georges Geret also perfect in his hoodlum character. Annie Cordy very surprising too, in such a film. Only the ending is a bit deceiving for my taste. Only mine.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Cool French Italian co-production
This is an icy Euro crime outing with a great cast. It's a shame Le Mataf is only available on French DVD with no English subs as 70's French crime movies are very under represented (unlike their Italian cousins). This may not have the balls out action and macho posturing of a Merli or Milian outing but Michel Constantin's crater face speaks volumes and there's an excellent safe cracking scene featuring plenty of sweat and wild camera compositions. Melville typified the sullen loner alongside hushed, whispered dialogue. The performances here mirror the maestros tone alongside the twisting narrative and laid back pacing. Stelvio Cipriani's lush score is another plus. Check it out.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed