Le manoir de la peur (1927) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Le manoir de la peur....
EdgarST26 April 2024
Made seven years after the release of «The Cabinet of Doctor Caligari», this admirable silent movie keeps alive the expressionist tradition and some of the morbid "caligarism" of that film: a twisted corridor in the titular mansion, landscapes and characters in silhouettes and a villain that resembles the somnambulist Cesare in stamp and misfortune, and Dr. Caligari himself with his insane schemes.

However, this story set in the French countryside is not a fantastic tale framed by a realistic prologue and epilogue like «Caligari», which define the central plot as a mental patient's obsession, but rather the events are all realistic: a couple whose romance is thwarted by a railroad worker, father of the bride; the arrival of a mysterious man of science whom the town looks upon with suspicion and fear; the curious training that his assistant performs in secret, with the chimpanzee Hello to achieve his ends... Everything is heading towards a tense ending in which two plot lines converge in a dynamic way, following premises of the dramatic montage "a la D. W. Griffith", with whom Machin worked in 1918 on «Hearts of the World.» According to the dramatic montage scheme, after dramatic action with an adrenaline overdose (which includes a frenetic train chante), calm and tranquility for the viewer is achieved by the opposite, in this case, a romantic ending.

Apart from everything, I liked to find another work by Alfred Machin, whose wonderful 8-minute rural drama «Le moulin maudit» (The Cursed Mill) I saw included in a 1909 film anthology. Colored with stencils, it is a short film made in Belgium about a love triangle that ends in tragedy. A photographer by profession, Machin was recognized for his early films about animals. «Le manoir de la peur....» was his last collaboration with his assistant Henry Wulschleger, with whom he co-directed some films with the popular chimpanzee Auguste, interpreter of the irresistible Hello. The restored version has an enjoyable rock soundtrack, which is a definite plus.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Derivative French Silent would be Shocker.
Mozjoukine16 July 2021
This one starts off like a silent French rural drama, shifts into a CALIGARI rip-off and ends up like a cut price LA ROUE. Alfred Machin and Henry Wulschleger only occasionally hit the right scary note or vaguely anti lynch mob message that they strive for. Their actors from Abel Gance movies (Romuald Joubé was the lead in J'ACUSE) are an unimpressive lot and the mix of remote provincial village actuality and studio decors is uneasy.

The good new is that it survives in a beautiful tinted restoration which runs near the right speed and has an original score. It's hard enough to see anything French from this period, I guess we shouldn't impose unreal standards of quality.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed