"Law & Order" Punk (TV Episode 1998) Poster

(TV Series)

(1998)

User Reviews

Review this title
12 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Guarding the Weaker Sex.
rmax30482331 December 2012
Warning: Spoilers
A man named Trine, a corrections officer from an upstate prison, turns up dead, shot twice after being made to get on his knees. Briscoe and Curtis has a little trouble tracking down the killer, a Puerto Rican who has a sister in the corrections facility where Trine worked.

The facility housed nothing but women and, men being what they are, many or most of the COs had girls, sometimes several, who did their bidding or were written up for fictional violations and punished. One of the girls, it turns out, had been repeatedly used as a sexual receptacle for the dishonorable Trine. When the girl tried to end the relationship, Trine had a colleague threaten the girl's family in Brooklyn. So the girl -- are you following this? As in most episodes, the plot is complicated and comes at you headlong. So, through her cell mate, the girl hired the Puerto Rican hoodlum to put a stop to Trine's peccadilloes, which he did, permanently, in an alley, with two 9 mm. bullets.

Two features make this episode a little unusual. One is that Angie Harmon, as the ADA, originally prosecuted the girl, who wound up with a particularly harsh sentence for a relatively minor offense. Harmon seems to hate the girl, believing her to be a psychopathic manipulator and liar, and there is considerable conflict between Sam Waterston, as her boss, and Harmon over the girl's culpability in this and previous affairs.

The second is the performance of Cara Buono as the young woman, Alice Simonelli, in prison who is exploited by Trine. She gives an exceptional performance, a mixture of anger, defiance, and terror, and she delivers it all not just in a working-class New York accent but with appropriate, emphatic Italian body language. She's attractive, with startled black eyes, but make up has turned her into a denizen of the prison system. In an earlier season, she played an elegant college girl who had cleverly organized a stable of whores among her classmates, which only demonstrates her range as an actress.

For what it's worth, the corrections officers are called just that. Only once or twice does the term of reference "guard" slip through. I've worked with COs on a movie, "Weeds," and they're very careful about the use of these terms because they help to establish a social border. You're either one of us -- in which case you say "corrections officer" or "CO" -- or you're not, and you say "guard."
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Guards say they're looking for dope, but they're looking for your pride.
Mrpalli7716 May 2018
Two black boys were playing american football in a playground, when one of them noticed a white middle aged man on the ground, shot dead. He begged before being killed on his knees. The victim, a correction officer, lived Upstate and he came to the Big Apple to pay a visit to his child, a football player. Detectives tried to collect information about the inmates who got parole in the last few months. Anyway the officer was not so clean: working in a women's prison, he used to blackmail prisoners (raping them from time to time); the only chance prosecutors had to reach the truth was to persuade a single mother (Cara Buono), currently in the prison hole, to speak. The gun used in the murder belonged to a scarred portorican, connected to her thanks to prison brotherhood. When prosecutors realized she had a miscarriage because of the rape, things got worse....

It's hard to have sympathy for the murdered guy as the episode moves on. Who is the real victim after all? Other guards are involved in the case, so all become very difficult, because they considered inmates like "cage animals". Eventually we learn some "shocking" personal information about Carmichael.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
V for Vendetta
TheLittleSongbird8 September 2021
One of the biggest appeals of 'Law and Order' has been the topics it addresses and issues that come with the topics addressed. Also with how they are explored, the execution more often than not was hardly sugar coated or trivialised and was often pull no punches in quality. On first watch, "Punk" struck me as a very good episode that does so much right. Despite disliking Carmichael's, speaking as somebody who usually likes her, attitude.

My feelings on "Punk" are pretty much exactly the same. It is still a a very good episode on the whole with many fantastic things, as well as a couple of things done not so well that were also sporadic recurring problems. It's not one of the best episodes of Season 9 and not one of the best of 'Law and Order', but still has plenty to show why 'Law and Order' is such a fine show and why it in its prime was my personal favourite of the franchise.

"Punk" is another case of one half being better than the other, with it starting off quite unexceptional and routine.

Also really didn't like Carmichael's selfish and non-empathetic attitude towards the case, which is laid on too thickly.

However, so much is done fantastically. It is a slickly made episode, the editing especially having come on quite a bit from when the show first started (never was it a problem but it got more fluid with each episode up to this stage). The music is sparingly used and never seemed melodramatic, the theme tune easy to remember as usual. The direction is sympathetic enough without being too low key.

Furthermore, "Punk" has a thoughtful script that like a lot of 'Law and Order' episodes raises interesting questions worthy of debate with somebody, the moral dilemmas of the case treated intriguingly. The story is tactful but also pulls no punches, making one feel sad and angry. Nothing is too simple or too complicated and the second half even is riveting and keeps one guessing the more complex it gets. The character writing and interaction are near-on point and the conflict has genuine tension.

While not caring for Carmichael's character writing, Angie Harmon still plays her very well and has settled likewise. Melnik is a great character with a lot of passionate energy. A big selling point with "Punk" is the exceptional performance of Cara Buono, who has a complex unsettling presence and makes her character feel real.

Concluding, very good. 8/10.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Punk - #9.8 - Loved Cara Buonos Performance!
dovenote14 June 2016
I remember seeing her in a Law & Order Criminal Intent episode and Vincent D'Nofrio and Katherine Erbe were heading the cast. I didn't catch her name then, but when I saw this Law & Order episode I recognized her, even though it was a totally different type of role. I think her acting in this episode was very convincing and moving. This was an episode that caused me to think and care about this character. When an actor or actress makes me want to care about them, no matter how flawed the character is, that, to me, is one of the main ingredients I look for in considering great acting! Cara Buono's portrayal in this role was,for me great acting! I'd go so far as to say she should have at least won an Emmy nomination for her role in this.
15 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Surprisingly strong Law and Order episode.
PWNYCNY2 August 2018
At first, in this episode the story seems contrived. A corrections officer is murdered in the community and a female inmate is accused of arranging the murder from inside a prison. The inmate claims that the corrections officer was raping her But the murder is not the main element that drives the story. The assistant DA, Harmon, who is female, is hostile toward the defendant and does not conceal her hostility. The question is: why is this assistant DA so hostile toward this one defendant? No one understands it. Out of all the cases this assistant DA has handled, why is the so focused on this one defendant? This mystery transform a rather unoriginal plot into something that creates interest. Soon, attention shifts away from the defendant to the assistant DA as she continues to fume over what she claims is one of the lowest human beings on the planet. Although the defendant has a checkered past, her rap sheet does not seem to suggest a record that is especially egregious. That means nothing to the assistant DA who is absolutely determined to get a murder conviction, even though the defendant was allegedly being raped. To find out why the assistant DA was so hostile, watch the episode. It contains one of Angie Harmpn's stronger performances.
14 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Cara Buono is the star
antfitz7 June 2020
This is a gripping story, but Cara Buono made this episode. Her performance is a standout! Why is she listed below the men? I had a difficult time finding out who she is. I just rewatched the episode for about the 4th time, always taken by her portrayal.
10 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
"I used to blame myself, but not anymore"
hanchilles18 March 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Abbie carmichael acting shines in this episode, the plot is amazing too, the lady who acted as Alice, 100/100 for her amazing acting, she can portray anger and sadness realistically too.

We see the growth of Abbie here as an attorney, personal grudge vs what is the right thing to do. McCoy takes a backseat in this episode which is fresh.

Who run the world? Girls!
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Bad choices
bkoganbing22 February 2015
Cara Buono's performance here as the working class girl who makes some bad choices and winds up in the state prison system dominates this particular Law And Order story. What also drives this story is the history between her and Angie Harmon.

Back in the day when Abbie Carmichael was working in the Narcotics Bureau Buono was one of hundreds of people she prosecuted. Buono made a really bad choice in that one, she was left holding the bag with her boyfriend's drugs. So instead of turning him in, she took the rap for him out of some misplaced sense of street loyalty. It wound her up in a women's prison where she joins the ladies' auxiliary of a gang called the Paganos and uses those connections to get a certain correction officer killed because he was harassing her.

The portrait of this victim is one of a true sleaze-bag, but one who would probably never be caught because of the code of silence among prison guards. After all they're the ones you have to rely on to get yourself out of tight spot if you find yourself in one with all those prisoners.

Tovah Feldshuh makes one of her guest appearances as Sam Waterston's favorite defense lawyer Danielle Melnick. The jury hears all about the victim and has a real problem here. I love Feldshuh's character she's such a passionate advocate in all her appearances.

I've known people like Buono in my life. They make bad choices and continue to make them. You love them, but you want to strangle them at times. I also have to say there's an element of narcissism in Buono's character the way she personalizes what Angie Harmon did back in the day. It's called doing your job.
10 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
I feel like sentencing Abby Carmichael to 8 1/3 to 25 after this episode
L_O_Addict30 November 2020
I've never warmed to Abby Carmichael as assistant DA, but she's utterly unbearable here. Her smug self-certainty and complete lack of empathy come to a head in this story of a woman, previously convicted by Carmichael of drug offenses, who has been a victim of repeated rape by prison guards. There's a revelation at the end of the episode that is supposed to put a new spin on Carmichael's attitude, but it's too brief and superficial. The overall feeling is one of frustration and anger, despite the terrific performance by Cara Buono.
16 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Episode staff got it very wrong.
pchartier-893926 March 2023
Law & Order S9,E8 'Punk' : a 1998 episode I'm viewing again on Prime. I probably saw the first presentation 25 years ago without noticing anything wrong. Now a senior, I realize I've become more attentive to details, more observant of mistakes, and less forgiving.

'Candy' is a young female inmate testifying in criminal court. Her acting is fine but something struck me as bizarre : her eyebrows are perfect, her eyelashes also perfect, her lipstick just perfect. Since when do inmates get to benefit from a professional makeup artist before going to court ?

Obviously a blunder by the support staff. They got the principal inmate character right (no makeup at all), but goofed for the other.

As I said, I notice more with time passing. Pros must act like Pros, and supervisors must supervise...
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
This is the episode that upset me the most...
Rwwood489 April 2015
Warning: Spoilers
When Brisco,and Green find Charlie Tyner murdered,and it leads them to the women's prison,and what goes on there. When Abby Carmichael has to go after Cara Buono. Abby turns on the selfish attitude towards Cara from her previous run in with Cara,where Abby over charged Cara.Then Abby blames Cara for all that has happened to her while in prison.I always like it when Daniel Melnik is defending her,or anyone. She is good. Her best question was to the guard "How is she to know that someone is there for her"? The guard replied "I guess not". That made the whole case. Then in the end Abby admits to being raped in college to her boss. It showed us that Abby had an agenda against Cara to hide her feeling on what happened to her years ago.Abby was wrong on all counts.I have run up against this treatment in the legal system before.The acting was great by everyone involved.
14 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Over Acting at Its Worse
figuress10 June 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Cara Buono overacted in this episode. I did not find her outrage constant face shaking and sputtering believable especially since she was clearly given leniency on the sentence that landed her in prison in the first place. I'm sure others in prison with her - especially her gang mates - would have informed her that she could have been given a harsher sentence.
0 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed