"Route 66" Same Picture, Different Frame (TV Episode 1963) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
When Love Kills
AudioFileZ17 May 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Want to see a later day Joan Crawford performance? Well, this isn't the great showcase you might hope for. Season four finds Route 66 struggling to weave some of it's magic and there's hope that a former screen icon may help. Only thing is the whole affair is hobbled by a dark and unmoving story.

Tod and Linc find themselves working at a dated historic Polish Springs Hotel and Resort with Tod assuming the role of the social director and Linc being the youth director. Joan Crawford stars as an aging woman of some social standing who has returned home to spend her later years where it all started for her. She is a dark complicated lady who never got the life she envisioned when she left with the young man who romanced and wed her only to wreck both of their lives. Linc is immediately drawn to her in a strange attraction where he seems to want to be a type of savior in her healing. He gets his chance as Morgan's estranged husband returns in a very creepy way. He seems to want to paint the masterpiece with her as the subject standing by a furnace no less, one that he fires up every chance he gets. In his quest to get his paramour in the right backdrop he ends up stalking her and killing a man in the process. The writers try for some comic relief with Tod staying busy fending off a young sixteen-ish gal who is vacationing with her parents to no avail - neither in the way of comic relief or a relationship that makes any sense. Sound convoluted? It most certainly is and in that there is no compelling entertainment despite some scenic and historic Poland Springs landmarks.

One thing is certain and that is Sterling Silliphant is fearless in his attempt to write heavy themes into Route 66. Mostly, throughout the previous three seasons he has succeeded, but when it falls flat, as it does here, it really lands with a "thud". To her credit, Joan Crawford plays the part she is given with sincerity, but, ultimately, her performance fails flat due to the script she is handed. Noteworthy only due to her appearance this episode is otherwise not recommended, particularly not for casual viewing.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Typical stalking drama raised a notch by the great Miss C.
mark.waltz31 October 2018
Warning: Spoilers
When I first saw Joan Crawford standing near a horse wagon in this very special episode of "Route 66", I began to wonder if she was a last minute replacement for Barbara Stanwyck who was usually the major Hollywood diva wearing leather boots and grooming a horse. Here, she's a feisty lady on the run from her estranged husband whom she believes is out to kill her for an accident he holds her responsible. Crawford emotes nicely, is likable, and has great on-screen chemistry with stars Martin Milner and Glenn Corbett. The episode sags in the middle with a sudden long scene with Tom Bosley, but fortunately builds to an exciting conclusion. At least unlike her "Man from U.N.C.L.E." appearance, she really has something to do.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/4/63 "Same Picture, Different Frame"
schappe18 January 2016
This is likely the first episode filmed for the fourth season. They are in Poland Springs Maine, (which gets credited in this and the next episode, "Come Out, Come Out Wherever You Are" as well as the fifth episode shown this year, "Build Your House With Their Backs to the Sea"). There is a very lengthy thread by a man named Robert Spears that is still on the message board for this series. Mr. Spears was working at Poland Springs when the company arrived to prepare for and film the episode and he has some interesting observations about his experiences and what the cast members were like when they were there, including a link to some on-set pictures:

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0053534/board/flat/41570440?p=1 He was involved with preparing the scenes in the boy's bunkhouse and the residence Joan Crawford, Glenn Corbert and the Sheriff's Deputy are riding toward when they get shot at. He also prepared the semi- comic brawl scene in "Come Out, Come Out Wherever You Are". A great book could be written about the residents of the mostly small towns the series filmed their episodes in across America and what they remember about the filming.

Crawford plays a woman who should obviously be about 20 years younger than the actress is, (she was about 60 at the time: like many actresses, determining her actual age is like trying to catch a butterfly). Her jealous lover is played by Patrick O'Neal, who was 36 at the time. He's a deranged artist who first discovered her as a young actress 20 years before, (an element introduced to cover Crawford's age but she would have been about 40 even then). She became his muse and his paintings reflect his ever-changing feeling about her. She got scared by his obsessiveness and in a struggle, he lost the sight in one eye. She's come home in an attempt to evade him but he shows up. She's gotten to know Linc, a camp counselor and he tries to help her. They both wind up captives of the by now totally deranged O'Neal.

Todd has another job at Poland Springs he never seems to be doing. Instead, he's comically pursued by a teenage girl with a crush on him. He never gets directly involved with Linc's story. His scenes are supposed to be comic relief but they hardly go with the over- wrought main story.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
"One of those handsome, mid-40's jobs"
lrrap4 February 2020
Thus does our hero Tod Stiles describe Hollywood Grande Dame Joan Crawford to a gas station attendant in this very uneven show. Does he mean that she represents the older, stylish female image that was fashionable in the 1940's...or does he mean to imply that she's currently in her mid-40's in terms of age?? If it's the latter, I'm very disappointed in his judgement.

Joan was c. 63 when she filmed this show and her "husband" Patrick O'Neal was 36. So why was he cast in the role, I wonder? Their on-screen age difference certainly doesn't help connect the viewer with the drama and characters.

I recently read a comment on the Internet (I thought it was on IMDB--?), describing this show (and Joan's performance) as "Strait-Jacket Without The Ax"....which I think is hilarious (referring, of course, to the William Castle shlocky shocker of 1964). Whoever it was that came up with that one should take a bow.

Joan certainly strikes a great, statuesque, well-poised image onscreen; she was an authentic, classic, Golden Age Queen of Hollywood. But it all seems somewhat out of place and contrived here...unlike the eccentric recluse played by Miriam Hopkins at the end of Season 3; now THAT's good casting.

All-in-all, "Same Picture" is OK in terms of entertainment and dramatic value. Nice location visuals. But what's with the freaky, bloody hand emerging from Joan's Cadillac trunk? At the very least, it could have helped her change the flat tire.

Then there's the Tod 'n "Binky" story......oi..... LR
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
JOAN CRAWFORD!!!
jessly811 June 2021
The chemistry between Joan Crawford and Glenn Corbett was quite good in my opinion. Joan Crawford gives a great performance as Morgan. A very enjoyable episode of classic TV series Route 66.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Rather amazing!
lor_14 January 2024
I suspect (or fantasize) that Stirling Silliphant was inspired to write this Gothic melodrama after watching Robert Aldrich's "Whatever Happened to Baby Jane?", as Joan Crawford is perfect casting as the lead in this strange tale that doesn't fit the format of "Route 66" but is nonetheless a standout episode.

Her strength, and unblinking dramatic style does wonders with a sort of Tennesse Williams character, oddly matched for a platonic May/December romance with Glenn Corbett's Linc, though I would have preferred Maharis had he not taken a hike from the show. Silliphant balances this perversely with another May/December situation for Milner, reduced to comic relief as the underage Jacqueline nCourtney makes a play for him, authentically jail-bait casting before she grew up to become a soap opera star.

The extended product placement aspect of the Poland Spring setting in Maine, with its still famed bottled water and the photogenic Poland Spring Hotel featured is a bit much, but director Philip Leacock does a good job of balancing the so-tangible realism of utilizing real locations with the fantasy aspect of the story. Patrick O'Neal underplays superbly as the escaped homicidal maniac, menacing but not in the usual horror movie cliched manner.

I was surprised to see Joan's Caddy convertible upstage the Corvette for a change, with my sympathy for the iconic car (the series' nominal if hero) nearly overwhelming my concern for the merely human characters for a moment.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed