America's Got Talent (TV Series) Semifinals 2 (2019) User Reviews

Semifinals 2

[bobcobb301 · 7/10 · 12 September 2019]

I am fine with judges being critical, far too often on shows they are not, but Howie Mandel's comments just seemed weird here. It didn't feel like he was calling out the right acts.

This is not going to be a great finale, the talent wasn't there this year, but there were some solid performers tonight.

First, I admire all the performers, but

[MiketheWhistle · 3/10 · 11 September 2019]

I have zero talent, and almost without exception I am impressed with the talent that people have. That does not mean that everyone with talent would I pay to see. I judge the talent and shows based upon who would I pay to watch.

With that said, this was one of the worst semi-finals although maybe on par with the prior semi. It's disappointing that so many with such talent that the semi-final was so underwhelming. I felt sorry for the dog act. I'm not sure if he was too distracted or what because he has done so much better. The magic act was simply a joke. The comedian was funny, but not overwhelming. As a general rule I don't like singing acts, so in the end it was simply sad to me.