"Stargirl" Summer School: Chapter Twelve (TV Episode 2021) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
The penultimate episode of Stargirl: Summer School plays out like an ordinary episode and that's the problem as it lacks an engaging plot and a frightening villain
Holt34428 October 2021
Summer School: Chapter Twelve is directed by Greg Beeman who also serves as producer for the show and couple of other well known shows, the direction is good but not great. I liked the way he choose to shoot scenes though. The episode's script was written by James Dale Robinson and his writing was felt throughout the episode with overall great writing and fantastic dialogue. The cinematography is good, with the sets and locations being great. All the departments did a terrific job with this episode.

The episode follows the events of the previous episode with Courtney, Cindy and Charles McNider having escaped Eclipso's realm. Chapter Twelve follows: Courtney seeking help from the unlikeliest of places. Meanwhile, Mike's search to find Thunderbolt leads him straight to his friend Jakeem, and Pat goes to extreme lengths to protect Rick.

There were a couple of good character interactions in this episode, but I didn't really find the acting to be quite on the same level as previous episodes. Luke Wilson gives a terrific performance as Pat Dugan, Brec Bassinger and Meg DeLacy deserves praise as well.

In my opinion, this was overall a good episode. But the thing is that it doesn't really feel like a penultimate episode, lots of things should have been in previous episodes. But having the entire cast in an episode was great to see and even Alkoya Brunson back as Jakeem Williams. My problem with the penultimate episode and many episodes before it is how the pace is too slow, and that the writers have failed in making Eclipso a menacing and frightening villain. He had the potential to both be great and frightening but ultimately failed with both, in my opinion. What could have helped was that people would have stayed dead, like Cindy for example. Seeing her "die" made me think Eclipso was a villain that could live up to his name at being one of the darkest villains out there but the writers have played it too safe. Yet here we are, the penultimate episode of a season that's been dragging on too long. The pacing would have been improved if it would have been a ten episode season instead of thirteen. It was overall a good episode but far from great.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Good set up for the finale. Kept me at the edge of my seat
ldamena27 October 2021
Cindy led this episode. Love the complexity of her character she's a villain but not a one note villain, there's so much more to her. If she keeps going this way I'll classify her as an anti hero. Also great character moments for Mike, Pat and Beth. Yolanda was meh but I'm glad she woke up. Ready for the finale next week.
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Oh yeah. It's all coming together.
wetmars31 October 2021
Warning: Spoilers
I am sorry if I have been behind some of the CW Episodes, it's just that my life has been lately busy so far. Interesting choice of music, in the beginning, I have to say. McNider says some stuff with Pat like Light injures Darkness since the Staff harmed Eclipso. Beth and Jade enter the Dugan House, and they immediately notice that Cindy is here. Cindy explains that she's fighting true evil. Oooo, so apparently. McNider has his goggles so the googles that Beth has been wearing aren't his. Okay so, I am calling him Chuck from now on since it's tricky to remember the name McNider. I usually get mixed up with MidNider, etc. Mike has been trying to find Thunderbolt for a while, spotting a big burger in front of a house. I'm sorry, but that looks so fake. Courtney tries to discuss with Yolanda telling her that she isn't the only one who killed once. Courtney has a good point that she isn't alone, even though she doesn't care as Cindy watches from the distance.

Pat pays a visit to Rick's older brother, begging him to not drop the charges since it can ruin his life as he's getting started after High School. He writes a note that says "Go to hell". Pat makes a good point that their parents gave him a chance to look after Rick, but he has always been abusive to him. God. I don't know if I've said this before, but Pat is my personal favorite character. "You're a bad guy. And whenever I run into so people like you. When I was growing up back in the Army... or today... makes me remember something about myself. I got some bad in me, too." Pat closes the blinds (( I forgot what they're called. )) as he panics. Holy **! Mike questions a guy who has possession of Thunderbolt where he has been. He answers that he flew away, and never came back for three or four hours. Mike questions him if he has ever heard of the Justice Society of America. The kid responds: "Is that a Boy Scout? Because I'm really bad at tying knots." Lol.

Yolanda received a note saying "I can't do this alone." Cindy enters the house through the window to tell her to not come back. Yet, we get a twist that Cindy isn't against Eclipso, but betraying Courtney. Cindy pushes her buttons revealing that she was the one who sent Yolanda's acceptance speech to everybody's phone at School, and leaves. I have to say, the way that she "leaves" is quite strange. When she disappeared, I thought it was Eclipso messing with Yolanda's mind, but whatever. Mike discusses with the boy about saving the world. "Before we save the world, could we do the dishes?" Lel. So yes, Rick is out of prison. Yolanda comes to Courtney's basement. Eclipso taunts Jade's dream where she experiences the death of the JSA. Courtney has a discussion with Cindy about defeating Eclipso. Eventually, they have to be bad to beat evil as the old JSA did. Eclipso stumbles upon Chuck and Beth. "I hope your not mad at me after what I did to your little girl." What a way to push someone's buttons. Eclipso promises to the two that he will become like God. Here we see a potential future where Courtney becomes evil and kills the JSA.

Thoughts?

Great episode that focuses on the JSA getting back together. Courtney's interactions with Cindy were great throughout the episode. Mike's relationship with his friend is quite convincing.

8/10.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Perfect set up
vzzrafcjr27 October 2021
We get a tense but entertaining episode with great moments of character with the stand outs being Courtney, Cindy and Yolanda a trully great episode in a great season.
5 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The stage is set
GomezAddams66627 October 2021
Warning: Spoilers
This episode was magnificent in its execution, the stage has been set for the big fight, and even though he is outnumbered, Eclipso id powerful enough to take them all.

Every single piece fell into place, the old and new JSA are teaming up along with some bad people, but there is a clear difference between bad and evil.

I am also happy to see Yolanda and ick back in the fold were they belong, next to Courtney and her family.

This season was successful at setting up Eclipso as a force to e reckoned with, a worthy adversary of the JSA.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
[6.7] All creamy now
cjonesas23 February 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Chapter 12: An episode with as much tension in it as the wonderful doggy wholeheartedly eating snacks!

Besides that, nothing much interesting, at least no more than the staff being healed, some family business, dish-washing and Green Lantern's daughter being sucked into her own dark world with a dark baby symbiote being the star of the last 15 minutes.

Eclipso has gone to dust and his menacing grim is all creamy now, besides his kid counterpart who's as menacing as ever.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Eclipso Is Not A Character. He's A Plot Device.
demigodshmurda28 October 2021
Warning: Spoilers
I think I finally understand why this season's been so unbearable for me, and it's not the slightly rose-colored glasses I wear when talking about season 1. The reason that this season has felt so disconnected is because it has no real villain.

Stargirl Season 2 is a truly fascinating project. It's a truly perfect example of what happens when you put too much focus into character. Now, normally I'd say that the most important aspect of a story is its characters, but in this case, I think the writers may have taken things in the wrong direction. Because the writers are doing an amazing job exploring the characters fundamental flaws and weaknesses, but are failing to have those characters drive the plot forward as a result. They're almost too caught up in exploring these characters emotions, that they're forgetting that they still have to tell a compelling story alongside that.

That's why when Eclipso suddenly has a plan to "become your god" in this episode, it feels like it comes out of nowhere! We don't know Eclipso as a character. We're told a lot about what Eclipso can do, and that he's pure evil, and that he corrupts everything he touches, and that he's unstoppable. But as a result, we know absolutely nothing about *who* Eclipso is. We know he makes you see the things you hate or fear the most, but we don't know *why* he does that. We don't know what motivates him until the SECOND TO LAST EPISODE OF THE SEASON. And even by then, it's a half-baked explanation. His only motivation is to become a god (of which I think he already is, as I'm fairly sure the character in the comics is the embodiment of God's wrath), and to corrupt Courtney Whitmore. However, the season's done absolutely nothing to set that up, and so when his plan is revealed, it literally comes out of nowhere and leaves the audience wondering how we got here.

That's why Eclipso isn't a character. He's an excuse for the writers to get back some old actors whose characters are dead and make our characters confront their fears. Is the fear aspect fascinating and one of the best parts of the season? Absolutely, yes! My favorite episodes of the season are when Eclipso has been playing with people's minds like Yolanda in "Summer School: Chapter Seven" and Courtney in "Summer School: Chapter Eleven". But outside of those episodes, and even within those episodes, there isn't a plot connecting the episodes together, and that comes from the villain having no motivation. And you know what? I think the writers realized that, but they'd already filmed too many episodes and they were behind schedule, so they gave Eclipso a motivation at the last moment to try and make it seem like this was their plan all along. But as I've already explained, it has the opposite effect that they intended.

That, to me at least, is why Eclipso is a plot device as opposed to being an actual character. He's never appeared to have any motivation for what he's doing, and only exists to show us character moments that are truly fascinating. The season is so frustrating because the writers just treat Eclipso as this "get out of jail free card" to do whatever they want. Most of what Eclipso does to force the characters to introspect is phenomenally done, but it makes the season feel too slow as a result. The writers seem so infatuated with their primary cast of characters, that they forgot to create an interesting villain to oppose them, and it shows!

That being said, this episode wasn't actually all bad. I really enjoyed a lot of the moments between Courtney and Cindy, and also when Cindy dropped the bombshell on Yolanda that *she* was the one who leaked Yolanda's pictures. I'm honestly so happy that she finally admitted to what she did! The writers didn't retcon it or forget it, they were saving it for a reveal down the line like this one, and I'm not gonna lie, it was a pretty great moment.

I also really liked Beth and Dr. McNider working together this week, and Beth finally seeming to make a friend. Dr. McNider even lets Beth call him "Chuck" which was really heartwarming.

And as always, Milo Stein's performance as Eclipso's human avatar is phenomenal, and this kid is the best actor on the show by a longshot.

But with the very few positives of this episode gone over, all we're left with is a penultimate episode that feels like we're still dealing with plots from five episodes prior. A great example of this is Mike's plotline of him trying to find the Thunderbolt. To me, this seems like a development we could've covered in "Summer School: Chapter Five". That episode had more than enough time to do so, and wasn't the greatest episode of the show by any means, so I think we should've had Mike and Jakeem meet up in during that episode instead of focusing so much on Mr. Deisinger, who was just going to disappear after this episode anyway. We can still have the faceoff in the school, but maybe we could have one less scene with him going crazy and painting, and instead replace it with some thing that's actually important to the season's plot.

The plot is also stunted by the fact that the writers seemingly weren't allowed to have Jenny and Jakeem in the entire season. I mean, Jenny was in the first two episodes of the season, and then disappeared for *seven* episodes straight despite having some fairly major buzz made about the character to promote the season, and appearing in *both* of the season's trailers. And Jakeem was only namedropped during the pilot, and then we finally got to meet the character in episode 3, but then he disappears for *nine* episodes when we could've been developing the character this whole time!

Don't get me wrong, this is far from the worst season of tv I've ever seen. But if the writers have any hope of getting me to come back for season 3, this season finale better be the best episode of the show. And spoiler alert, I don't really have any confidence that the writers can pull it off at this point. I'm open to being proven wrong, but my expectations are gonna be set fairly low for next week's finale.

I mention in every review that I loved Stargirl's first season, and it's not just because of the beautiful character work. It's because Stargirl was a self-contained story. And if I'm being honest, I don't think the writers ever intended to get a second season. And believe it or not, I think the show should've stayed at just season 1. It's very rare that we have something as great as Stargirl's first season, and it's even more rare that something that great is able to just end. We live in an age of spinoffs and sequels, and this show is unfortunately falling victim to it.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
The formula is showing through.
rorygunn27 October 2021
Sadly the formual that ruined the Flash is once again rearing it's ugly head in Stargirl. She mopes around about how she's unsure and how she can't do it alone then gets a pep talk from either her mom or Pat. Also again why call this Stargirl if you're not going to let your title hero be the main hope for defeating the evil and instead have another side character in this case the over powered Mary Sue daughter of Alan Scott aka Green lantern. It's seems to be setting up her as the one who defeats the big bad meanine or Eclipso as he called in the show. The should have just called this The JSA. I hate that they stuck her with a team. It should have just been her and Pat and no one else. But sadly the TPTB couldn't allow a strong individualistic character who stands for something.
5 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Season full of fillers
AshBoshog28 October 2021
Warning: Spoilers
This season could of been so much better just by making it shorter and having more focus on eclipso who we still just know as evil guy that wants to be god. Yolanda goes back to the team with a bad excuse that just makes the entire yolanda episode a waste of time.

You could easily skip 3 fillers this season and you would only miss out on minor details that no one really cares about.

Remove the fillers or make them worth watching!
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed