The Boy Who Couldn't Swim (2011) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
The Journey May Be The Companion
thomasdosborneii12 October 2013
This was a very beautiful film with two young actors whose faces were very expressive of their personal sense of unsureness and disconnectedness with the world, yet wishing to demonstrate a bravado and control of their personal circumstances. The opening shots of the film showed the yearning and glistening hope in the eyes of the boy, Rasmus, as he looked out the train window, contrasted with the harsh face of a middle-aged stranger sitting next to him on the train whose face showed the angry lines of a firm acceptance of his place in hard world where dreams won't come true. One can see in that that youth is not apt to find much of value from people such as those, who are more apt to destroy their spirit than they are to ignite it.

In the train station, the other boy, Niklas, almost by a kind of bodily magnetism instantly connects with Rasmus as someone he can trust to help him by holding a stolen item while he escapes from men who are pursuing him. A while later, Niklas, having escaped from the pursuing men, meets up with Rasmus and while it seems that Rasmus has a vague destination he is heading for that he doesn't feel like revealing to Niklas, Niklas convinces him that they need to go there together with Rasmus riding in the cart of Rasmus's bicycle cart. And that really was the true journey, the two of them toward, or with, each other, they who share certain personal circumstances and need.

This action of them traveling together seemed to put them together in their own isolated bubble. Much of the movie was simply their traveling together throughout the city of Copenhagen from one destination to another (which I appreciated seeing, as while I have passed through Copenhagen, I haven't seen very much of it), but the beauty of the city, the simple shared exuberance of the boys as they felt the wind in their hair and a feeling of their own motive power, and the various expressions on their faces, sometimes wide open, sometimes cautiously masked, tell the true story without a need for words. And what words there were, were pointed and expressive, and throughout those conversations the boys were continually reaching out in yearning for connection, and then drawing back into unsureness, wavering on that balance beam between "yes I need" and "no I don't".

The title of the movie, "The Boy Who Couldn't Swim", made me think of a wise Jewish saying that I learned about in a psychology book, "A father's job is to teach his children how to swim." While at first that seems trivial, you come to realize that "swimming" is metaphorical of leaving the safety of home and venturing out bit by bit into an alien and dangerous world (or an uncaring and exploitative one). The father is not to hang onto his children, but to help them grow up into a secure adulthood. So what of those children who have not been "taught how to swim?" How do they maneuver out in this world without having had a secure center to start out from? Perhaps they can have another chance, by finding helpers along the way, if only they can recognize them and take the risk of connecting with them when they find them.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Some okay moments, but overall weak
Horst_In_Translation24 November 2015
Warning: Spoilers
"Drengen der ikke kunne svømme" or "The Boy Who Couldn't Swim" is a Swedish half-hour short film from 4 years ago. It's basically a road trip with two boys and of course they discover during that time what their sexuality is really like. I must say if this had run for only 15 minutes max I may have been more generous with this rating, but for 30 minutes it had a couple moment when I felt it actually did drag a bit. I am not familiar with writer and director Anders Helde and I also don't know the actors in here, but I guess only people from Denmark will, if at all. Anyway, this is not among the worst gay-themed short films I have seen and I have seen a lot, but also nowhere near the best, somewhere in the middle I guess. People who enjoy these movies, can maybe check it out. Everybody else can skip and isn't missing much.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
nice
Kirpianuscus15 January 2017
two boys. sketches of families. memories of one from them about a special day. a film about survive and about a form of friendship, remembering Proust and a lot of films about same theme. nice, beautiful but, maybe, too long. because a concentrate story was better. like many short films, it is about feelings more than support for a story. and this is the basic obstacle for define in the best manner. because it is a film about solitude and need of one to meet his mother, for the other to survive. the kiss scene is too ambiguous for define the film as part of a genre. and this does "The Boy Who Could Not Swim" seductive but not memorable.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed