Homophobia (II) (2012) User Reviews

Brilliantly made although unnecessary

[Rodrigo_Amaro · 8/10 · 16 July 2013]

A young soldier (Michael Glatschnig) finds out he's in love with one of his mates. Problem is that when you're confined to a homophobic/macho dominated space filled with guns like a military base is, you cannot show what you feel because it leads to trouble. And that's what happens when he gets picked on by another soldier (Günther Strumlechner) who sort of discovered his secret when the three of them were in the shower. But the moment that matters is when he finally has a confrontation with the object of his affection on a night that will change his life.

I know the target audience tend to skip movies like this one and go for the colorful and joyful side of the force (the romantic comedies, the happy endings, the positive love stories) but the persisting hearts will like this for its ultimate message of hope. Other than that, it's a good opportunity to see how talented the director is, in knowing how to make a gripping story, strangely exciting (the homo-erotic images are presented in twisted contexts. Example: when the main character is sexually teased by his bully, a frightening and tense moment but very sexy as well), and beautifully filmed.

Certainly a reality to many people out there, and probably presented time and again in many movies, and although liking what it tried to do, I don't see much need in projects existing today. I think if we want to see something similar we can look at what's already existing on the subject. The amount of obstacles faced by gay teens (and adults as well) is already a matter of countless preoccupations, and even while trying to be a help to their cause, the movie only accomplishes half of its intent since most of the time is too focused on fear, rejection, demoralization and prejudice issues rather than the good stuff, so to speak, like the human need for love, respect, affection, tolerance and acceptance.

A very touching drama with some edgy suspense. 8/10

Tense short

[laduqesa · 7/10 · 20 April 2023]

First of all, I'm absolutely horrified that the storyline published here in IMDB recounts the whole of the action and narrative. This site polices spoilers in reviews but this was one huge spoiler. I can't see a way to report it.

In the result, the film was accomplished enough to hold the attention and build tension even though one knew more or less what was going to happen.

The bully Jürgen would appear to be a closet case and is forever victimising Michael. Michael's friend Raphael runs with the crowd. In such a closed community the squadron commander can do little without an actual complaint. However, as it was the last night, I'm surprised one wasn't made - there'd have been no repercussions possible.

The final scenes are a good example of the desperation of gay teens. The suicide rate for this cohort is vastly greater than for the age group overall. Both boys were frightened. I loved this ending.

Enough to pass film school on

[gizmomogwai · 6/10 · 23 December 2017]

With a lot of technical competence, a provocative beginning, an atmospheric, chilling end-credit sequence and not much more, Homophobia is a short film looking at, well, homophobia in the Austrian Army. Homophobia in the '90s military is a familiar topic, but as a plus, few will be aware of how much it existed in Austria. Actually, homophobia in the form of homoeroticism- the bully fondles the closeted gay soldier- feels a bit unnatural. The short runs 20 minutes, but with so little in between, the question is why?

nothing new. at the first sigh

[Kirpianuscus · 18 August 2016]

the message is far to be new. but it remains sensitive. and the use of army life , the status of drawing - like many other short movies - the precise use of theme, the suggestion as good instrument for a coherent and poetic work are few virtues who give a delicate force to the film. in fact, it is a film about solitude. and the feminine traits of Josef Mohamed does the story different by many other films with the same theme. this is, in fact, the detail who saves the film. a vulnerable young man looking escape from the life after military service. a bully who hides, maybe, his sexual orientation - the scene from locker room could be a clue- the dialogue of two teenagers about future projects. and the last night on the border. nothing new at the first sigh. but presented in smart manner. and this is a real virtue.

A Rather Empty Short

[Theo Robertson · 5/10 · 7 April 2014]

With a title like HOMOPHOBIA you know right away what the theme revolves around . It's a story that's been done before . Perhaps even done a bit too often . A young man in the rough tough world of a macho culture he's gay and becomes victimised for it . Thankfully writer/director Gregor Shimidinger doesn't feel the need to smack the audience over the head with a PC crowbar telling us how we should feel about the themes put forward in the film and I started to think maybe the point of the short was to pass comment on conscription . I did know that Austria was one of the very few countries in the Western World to still continue conscripting young men in to mandatory military service , a tradition that most continental armies have rightfully scrapped in the 21st Century . Watching HOMOPHOBIA I doubt if that is what the film is saying and it's difficult to understand what the point of the film is . There is some emotional tension involved but it doesn't really go anywhere and paradoxically it ends up being both melodramatic and not as dramatic as it could have been . All in all I found it a rather pointless and empty short film

Just the usual

[Horst_In_Translation · 4/10 · 17 June 2015]

This is a 23-minute short movie from 3 years ago about a young man in the military and he is gay. Short films have been a very popular genre for films about homosexuality for a very long time now. There is nothing in this one here that wasn't already done in the past and frequently better. Just the same ingredients. The film already starts off very weak when we see a man put a gun into another man's mouth and we have no idea at all what was going on. Obviously Gregor Schmidinger, the director and writer, chose a path for his 3rd short movie that means style over substance. Then there is a scene where a young man is assaulted physically and verbally in a shower by other man because they think he is a homosexual. And then there is his superior who tells him that he cannot help if he isn't entirely honest to him. And finally there is a man trying to kiss another man, even if the latter just told that he gets head from a girl actually. Still, he must be a homosexual right? I mean it's night, there are two young men out there on their own. There has to be some physical intimacy, hasn't there? And finally, there is also some over-the-top drama. I wonder if Schmidinger has the talent to actually make a non-gay themed film, because this one here is evidence enough he should stop making these films. This isn't even his first short movie on the issue and yet it turned out pretty bad. He also definitely needs a lesson in subtlety. Not recommended.

Good but a little too familiar in what it does

[bob the moo · 6 April 2014]

I'm not really target audience for this story of a young homosexual man who is serving his time in the forces with other young men on border patrols. It shouldn't matter of course since the film should be able to make me feel even if I cannot directly relate. Mostly it does this although it takes its time to make a simple point. The narrative is familiar, young guy is teased and bullied because the others either know or suspect that he is gay and this heads to a sort of confrontation when out on patrol. It does feel like old ground but it is still well done. The film contains images that highlights the sexuality of the place to the character of Michael, although never suggests it is coming from him or that he is creating it. This feeds into a mix of sexual tension and outright tension in a couple of places and these are done well.

The final scenes are where the film should deliver and it does, but not as strong as I would have liked. It tends towards the melodramatic a bit too much and I would have liked the dialogue and characters to be been stronger when it came to it. It does still work for what it is though and I did feel for Michael and his struggle, but in the end I didn't really feel like the film had done anything that I hadn't been expecting or hadn't already known. It is still nicely made and Schmidinger works well with the camera close to bodies as well as working in the darkness of the snow covered forest, just needed a little bit more in the material to go beyond the familiar.