The Forgotten Angel of Bastogne (2014) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Giving a brave lady her due....
planktonrules25 September 2017
This is a very well made documentary, made about a very seldom mentioned heroine of the infamous Battle of the Bulge, in late December, 1944. While folks often remember General Patton or have seen films like "Battleground" or the television series "Band of Brothers", they have focused on the soldiers enduring harsh conditions in this war in Belgium. Instead, this focuses on a diminutive local nurse, Augusta Chiwy, and her willingness to risk life and limb to help the wounded and dying.

The show features the British historian and researcher, Martin King. He discusses what he discovered about Augusta and the doctor she worked with, Jack Prior. It's recreated beautifully in the film but also features an added surprise...he finally was able to track down the lady...in her 90s and he worked to bring her recognition for her service to humanity. Very well made and inspiring...and worth your time.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
The life of a nearly forgotten heroine
Miles-1026 March 2017
Augusta Chiwy was a Belgian nurse who treated many wounded American soldiers during the Battle of the Bulge. There were only two nurses at the army medical aid station in Bastogne, Belgium, in December of 1944. There was another army hospital on the other side of town, but neither facility was well staffed or well stocked. They had almost no medical supplies because the town was surrounded by Germans for several days. During the siege, the Germans fired explosives into the town in an almost constant, nerve-racking barrage.

Nurse Chiwy and army surgeon Dr. Jack Prior became a team even though she only spoke a little English and he only spoke a little French. They once amputated a man's gangrenous foot and hand with cognac for anesthetic, hydrogen peroxide for disinfectant, and a serrated knife. (They didn't even have a surgical scalpel!) Chiwy not only administered the anesthetic and disinfectant, but she was the one who closed up (using God-knows-what for sutures).

Some of the American soldiers did not want to be touched by Chiwy because she was black. (Her father was Belgian and her mother was from the Belgian Congo.) Dr. Prior pointed out to these men, with more or less subtlety, that the alternative was that they could join the men who could not be treated at all and who were almost certainly going to die.

On one occasion, Chiwy and Prior commandeered a truck and drove to a snowy battlefield to bring wounded soldiers back to the aid station. Chiwy, who was under five feet tall, dragged a man with a leg wound to safety while dodging machine gun bullets.

When the Germans dropped a bomb directly on the aid station, Prior and Chiwy happened to be in the building next door where someone had invited them for a Christmas drink. Chiwy received minor injuries while 30 men and the other nurse, Renee Lemaire, were killed instantly. Prior and Chiwy worked with others to rescue the remaining patients from the demolished building.

Historian and film producer Martin King had heard of Lemaire but only belatedly learned of Chiwy from a local historian in Bastogne. He set about finding out more about her, and his research became the basis of this documentary. He found Chiwy living in a retirement home, where she graciously allowed King to make a fuss over her even though she kept saying that what she had done was not all that special. King made it his mission to persuade the Belgian and U.S. governments to recognize Chiwy for what she had done.

Chiwy, Prior and probably the other army doctor (who was a dentist by training) suffered from PTSD. Chiwy would occasionally become mute. Once, during the siege, something happened that made her want to scream but when she opened her mouth, no sound came out. For years afterward she would sometimes have trouble speaking. Similarly, Dr. Prior went back to the United Sates but found himself incapable of treating live patients who could experience pain; so he became a pathologist, a doctor who deals only with people who are already dead. The dentist became temporarily blind which was either caused by an hysterical reaction or a concussion, which was never made clear, perhaps even to him.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
There are many "forgotten angels".
sadietom8 September 2018
This was a fascinating documentary and I thoroughly enjoyed it. Augusta Chiwy deserved to be recognized. As a nurse, I've often wondered why there aren't more films that explore the contribution of WWII nurses -- there are thousands of "forgotten angels". Nurses followed the GIs on D-Day, set up 500 bed hospitals in a matter of days, sometimes had to dismantle them and evacuate just as quickly and were injured and killed during the line of duty. Yet, I can only recall 1 or 2 films that didn't feature them in the role of handmaiden or as a romantic interest. Thousands of young women volunteered for the Nurses Corps during WWII. I'd like to see a "Saving Private Ryan" or "Band of Brothers" film featuring them.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Fantastic story of bravery and heroism and credit to the makers for bringing the story to light.
chanel246892046823 December 2019
This is a story that crosses cultural and racial barriers and teaches us that in the face of adversity humans irrespective of their backgrounds can be capable of outstanding acts of bravery and kindness. This documentary has all the hallmarks of a fantastic fascinating story that is enhanced by the fact it actually happened and deserves to be made in to a film in order to reach more people and inform them of the astonishing bravery of this brave young nurse and the doctor she worked with. It is credit to the makers of this documentary in acknowledging the bravery of these medical staff and giving them a platform where their story has been rightfully told.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Sensational
ronnienahem15 December 2022
I don't often write reviews but after watching this wonderful documentary I had to. I've read many books and watched many shows about Bastogne .in band of brothers there was a heartbreaking and thrilling episode about Bastogne where I first learned about these 2 brave heroic nurses. This documentary was so detailed, emotional,truthful that it was a pleasure to watch. The backstory's on the surgeon,dentist , nurses and other historical figures really packed an emotional punch. Even the black and white war footage was excellent. I believe I read that this documentary won an Emmy award for best documentary. We'll deserved Bravo.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
WOW!
granpafox11 February 2018
I personally thought the doc was not put together well but the underlying story is a kick in the pants!

How did this woman go 67 years without recognition from Belgium or the United States? Should be required viewing for every American nurse and soldier! You don't have to be American to be great for America!

Her story would make a great feature film but who would tell it?
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed