A Fool (2014) User Reviews

Not complicated, not colourful

[monchocolat · 7/10 · 27 June 2016]

The film is made in a traditional way with a clear structure and story line. Quite a simple story in a quasi-documentary style. The story happens in a few locations - the main character Latiaozi's bungalow, Datouge or 'big head brother's' car, a high slope in Latiaozi's village and the police station. The story unravels mainly in the above locations back and forth. It's a little like a documentary in that it records people's everyday life. The songs played in big head brother's car are from almost ten years ago, which is probably the time background of the story. The TV drama that Latiaozi and his wife Jinzhizi watch seem to be an old Hong Kong series.

The actor/director Chen Jianbin's northwestern accent, which sounds like a Mandarin speaker attempting to speak a dialect with no avail, isn't convincing at all, although Chen himself is originally from northwestern China.

Too many boring fixed-position lenses make the viewer bored

[yoggwork · 6/10 · 19 February 2019]

Too many boring fixed-position lenses make the viewer bored. The story is still interesting. Unfortunately, it was completely destroyed by the lens language of this literary model. Chen Jianbin's wooden face is really suitable for such a spoon role, which is unfortunate for Jiang Qinqin. The dubious passage is really in tune.

A Revealing Tragi-Comedy from China

[drsatsahs · 9/10 · 13 July 2017]

I viewed this film on a trans-Pacific flight recently. It did not disappoint. It is another in a growing body of films from the 5th generation of mainland Chinese directors onward that captures the pathos of living in a society where trust of anyone outside the family risks loss of face or worse.

In "A Fool," anyone with "ren qing," or a heart for the plight of common people, is susceptible to playing the fool. But this film is not merely a cautionary tale as it richly reveals the irony first captured in The Beatles song, "The Fool on the Hill," albeit not deliberately. The film forms a question for the viewer: Who is the real fool in a country where civil society is so lacking and where the government does little to encourage it much more inspire it?

I was genuinely touched by misadventures of the sheep farmer who tries to do the right thing to such a consistent degree that he has gained notoriety in town for it. But his reputation is tainted by a gnawing sense that he is ridiculed more than admired for his simple humanity. Even his dignity is called into question by his abiding wife and his would-be benefactors, adding an element of pathos, to what are otherwise quite funny retorts bordering on gallows humor.

It helps if the viewer already has an appreciation for this brand of humor as well as some socio-cultural understanding of rural life in contemporary China, although it is not necessary.

What use is being good?

[axapvov · 4/10 · 11 May 2023]

A (deceptively?) simple moral tale on goodness and foolishness. At first I thought it would be a bit infuriating but it isn't because any dumb decision is presented with humor and sweetness. The plot follows a simple man who, along with his wife, tries to make sense of the events that unfold when he crosses paths with a mentally challenged homeless man. It might not be award material but it's well put together, I liked it.

Chinese films like this one sometimes feel unsubtle, though I appreciate this style after hundreds of cynical and needlessly obtuse movies. This one moves along very nicely, it's lighthearted and it has an interesting conclusion. Is earth wasted on us? Are good people always bullied? What's the cost/gain of helping/asking for help? Side note, I thought the wife was cute, turns out she's a drop-dead gorgeous opera singer. There yo go.