After long consideration, and reading mixed reviews, I finally sat down to binge this show. First of all: it's not bad. Not bad at all, in fact I wish this was the worst show in recent years. Without getting into too much detail, let's see the pros and cons.
The visuals are excellent, the cinematographer's work, the lighting, the locations and sets, the overall look of the show is exceptionally good. The cast, and pretty much all the performances are excellent. The music is a bit generic for my taste, but the soundtrack does not take away anything from the 'feel' of the show. The basic premise, all the ideas the script is based on, are surprisingly good and fresh. Now the cons: there are stories that do not need forced mystery and out of the blue twists...
The balance between predictable and surprising is key, and it's not very well done in this case. The biggest problem is the pacing: the first half of the season is slower than what I can comfortably call 'slow burn'. It's pretentiously slow, right to the point where it becomes boring. Not enough tension is built up, or if it's there... the pacing kills it: there is just too much time between certaing setups and payoffs so that the viewer simply forgets, why certain scenes are important. It's confusing.
SPOILERS ahead (if it's possible to spoil a show that's almost a year old): there are four major reveals in the first season. The first one is merely a slight hint that is way too subtle, one of my major issues. Mark almost hits Helly in the parking lot, driving home, and the scene is easily skipped, it only shows the viewer the fact that even after 3 minutes outside the severed space, they don't recognize each other. (It is revealed later, why it was important, but so much time passes that the moment loses its weight in the story.
The second one (the neighbor is the protagonist's boss) is fairly well done, the only problem is its predictability. The third major reveal (Mark's wife is "alive" and works at the company) is totally messed up and unnecessary, and feels forced. The last one in the season, that Helly is the next CEO of the company, and the whole show is her publiciy stunt is not bad at all, as an idea, but extremely poorly executed, and its timing is way off.
The biggest problem is that we are served with about 8 hours of content from which more than half is useless filler that does not move the plot forward at all, and the majority of the important things are cramped into the last 20 minutes or so of the finale. This kills the whole concept.
In my opinion, this story would have been much more interesting if it would have been cut into a 2 hour movie, with the same cliffhanger to bait the sequel.
Nevertheless: great cast, stunning crew effort, technically almost flawless ---- too bad it's borderline boring.
The visuals are excellent, the cinematographer's work, the lighting, the locations and sets, the overall look of the show is exceptionally good. The cast, and pretty much all the performances are excellent. The music is a bit generic for my taste, but the soundtrack does not take away anything from the 'feel' of the show. The basic premise, all the ideas the script is based on, are surprisingly good and fresh. Now the cons: there are stories that do not need forced mystery and out of the blue twists...
The balance between predictable and surprising is key, and it's not very well done in this case. The biggest problem is the pacing: the first half of the season is slower than what I can comfortably call 'slow burn'. It's pretentiously slow, right to the point where it becomes boring. Not enough tension is built up, or if it's there... the pacing kills it: there is just too much time between certaing setups and payoffs so that the viewer simply forgets, why certain scenes are important. It's confusing.
SPOILERS ahead (if it's possible to spoil a show that's almost a year old): there are four major reveals in the first season. The first one is merely a slight hint that is way too subtle, one of my major issues. Mark almost hits Helly in the parking lot, driving home, and the scene is easily skipped, it only shows the viewer the fact that even after 3 minutes outside the severed space, they don't recognize each other. (It is revealed later, why it was important, but so much time passes that the moment loses its weight in the story.
The second one (the neighbor is the protagonist's boss) is fairly well done, the only problem is its predictability. The third major reveal (Mark's wife is "alive" and works at the company) is totally messed up and unnecessary, and feels forced. The last one in the season, that Helly is the next CEO of the company, and the whole show is her publiciy stunt is not bad at all, as an idea, but extremely poorly executed, and its timing is way off.
The biggest problem is that we are served with about 8 hours of content from which more than half is useless filler that does not move the plot forward at all, and the majority of the important things are cramped into the last 20 minutes or so of the finale. This kills the whole concept.
In my opinion, this story would have been much more interesting if it would have been cut into a 2 hour movie, with the same cliffhanger to bait the sequel.
Nevertheless: great cast, stunning crew effort, technically almost flawless ---- too bad it's borderline boring.
Tell Your Friends