Change Your Image
vivichan46
Reviews
Lost in Translation (2003)
I don't like this movie
Lost in Translation is love story set in Tokyo. Bob is a famous actor who comes to Tokyo for work, while housewife Charlotte is in Tokyo because of her husband's job. They feel lonely, happen to meet and fall in love. However, Bob has to go back America and their love is in vain.
Director Sophia Coppola once lived in Tokyo and has said in interviews that when she first came to Tokyo, she felt as if she had come to another planet. It seems that since that time she was interested in making a movie in Tokyo, and a wonderful representation of Tokyo, capturing the look of neon, buildings people. It is a good movie for people to learn a lot about Japan. However, there are several things I don't like about this film.
The first is that Japanese are shown as lower or less than westerners, as shown literally in the scene where Bob is shown on an elevator with the diminutive Japanese, or when Bob laughs at the Japanese for being unable to distinguish between the sounds of "R" and "L".
Second, I couldn't understand what Coppola wanted to express. Bob and Charlotte happen to meet in Tokyo and fall in love. However, Bob had to back to America. I wonder what Coppola wanted to express. This story's subject is very vague and should have been expressed more clearly. That is why I can't understand why this work was nominated for Oscar and Golden Globe awards.
------------------
Suwingu gâruzu (2004)
I like this movie
Set in a country high school, Swing Girls is the story of a group of female students absorbed in playing and learning the pleasure of music. Tomoko is a typical high school student who along with her classmates one summer day delivers lunch to members of the brass band playing at a baseball tournament. But because the food has been out in the summer heat, the band members get food poisoning and Tomoko and her friends have to substitute for bed-ridden brass band. The girls start practicing instruments and at first aren't very serious about it but they gradually come to enjoy themselves and their lives are changed. In this process, they get together and learn friendship and love and the audience has the chance to watch them grow.
This director is of the film is Fumiharu Yaguchi, who most famous work is the popular Water Boys, a film about male high school students who start a synchronized swimming team. So, Swing Girls and Water Boys are alike in that ordinary students succeed in the end. The cast of Swing Girls consists of 16 girls and 1 boy lead ably by Juri Ueno in the role of Tomoko. One of Japan more popular actors, Naoto Takenaka, does another fine job playing the part of the powerless teacher.
One of the best things about Swing Girls is that the cast really play their own instruments. Most had no experience playing, so they practiced very hard for three months. These authentic performances help convey the pleasure of simply played music. It seems the instruments used in the film sold at very high prices after this movie was released.
On the negative side, there are some scenes that seem impossible. For example, some students suddenly are able to play their instrument very well without any practice. In the scene in which the students are chased by a wild boar, no one is ever caught or injured. If these scenes were made more realistic, I think this movie could be any even more wonderful work.