It is basically a question, more than a film . About fundamental decisions between duty and compassion, about status and meaning of teacher and about good faith as sharp tool. Admirable performance of Marie Bunel, inspired fotography and great , concentrated story. A film proposing old what must do ? and that provocative detail remains the great virtue of it.
5 Reviews
the choice
ferguson-65 December 2019
Greetings again from the darkness. As youngsters, most of us enjoyed school field trips. Escaping the sterile classroom environment to get out and see the real world was always a welcome event. Of course, we never thought about the added stress and challenges faced by teachers and escorts on those trips. For us it was an adventure.
French writer-director Paul Marques Duarte channeled his personal experience with a Sudanese boy in the refugee camp of Calais and developed this impactful short film that has much to say about inherent humanity in both youngsters and adults. Originally titled "Find Harbor for a Day", the story was co-written by Blandine Jet.
A group of students is on the bus when the driver slams on the brakes to avoid hitting a 15 year old boy in the street. A teacher locks eyes with the boy as the bus proceeds to the port, where the class is to board a ferry for their trip from France to England. As the teachers round up the students for security checks, the youngster from the street reappears and tries to blend in with the group of students as they board the ferry. Teacher Adele quickly analyzes the situation and plops her own ball cap onto the boy's head. Through all the confusion, the boy is allowed on the ferry. No words are exchanged between the teacher and the boy.
The teacher is played by well-known and well-respected French actress Marie Bunel, and the boy by N'Tarila Kouka. Clearly he's a runaway migrant, so the pertinent question is ... are the actions of the teacher heroic or foolish? Her fellow escort confronts her for putting them all at risk. The students figure out quickly what she has done and their reactions tell us much.
Duarte's film has been very well received at film festivals, and although it's filled with tension and expertly filmed and acted, its greatest value may be pushing us to question our own thoughts and reactions. What would we do in this situation ... and why?
French writer-director Paul Marques Duarte channeled his personal experience with a Sudanese boy in the refugee camp of Calais and developed this impactful short film that has much to say about inherent humanity in both youngsters and adults. Originally titled "Find Harbor for a Day", the story was co-written by Blandine Jet.
A group of students is on the bus when the driver slams on the brakes to avoid hitting a 15 year old boy in the street. A teacher locks eyes with the boy as the bus proceeds to the port, where the class is to board a ferry for their trip from France to England. As the teachers round up the students for security checks, the youngster from the street reappears and tries to blend in with the group of students as they board the ferry. Teacher Adele quickly analyzes the situation and plops her own ball cap onto the boy's head. Through all the confusion, the boy is allowed on the ferry. No words are exchanged between the teacher and the boy.
The teacher is played by well-known and well-respected French actress Marie Bunel, and the boy by N'Tarila Kouka. Clearly he's a runaway migrant, so the pertinent question is ... are the actions of the teacher heroic or foolish? Her fellow escort confronts her for putting them all at risk. The students figure out quickly what she has done and their reactions tell us much.
Duarte's film has been very well received at film festivals, and although it's filled with tension and expertly filmed and acted, its greatest value may be pushing us to question our own thoughts and reactions. What would we do in this situation ... and why?
What a great short film.
info-781843 August 2020
An emotional short film
hefaj-5843214 April 2020
In "Harbor" (original title: "Find Harbour For A Day"), English teacher Adèle (Marie Bunel) is taking her school children to a trip to the United Kingdom and they're on their way to the ferry to Bournemouth. Everything seems to be going fine until a 15 year old boy jumps in front of their bus. Luckily no one gets hurt.
Still shaken up about what could have happened, Adèle and her children make their way to security. They see the same young boy again. This time, he's trying to fit into their class to get on the ferry. Adèle knows that if she takes the boy, who has no papers, on the ferry with them that this would be illegal. Her teacher's instinct rules over that thought and so she gets him on board.
It seems that the boy isn't talkative at all and so connecting with him is harder than Adèle thought it would be. While she's trying to do everything she can to get through to the boy, he's doing things he's not supposed to do. Going to places on the boat where he shouldn't be.
It all goes sideways during one night when he's caught by the security because he was on forbidden ground. What will happen to him and Adèle now that her actions are about to be revealed?
While there's no "based on real-life events" sign at the beginning of the film, this movie is partly based on reality. Director Duarte mentioned that when he was helping at the refugee camp in Calais, he met a young boy who wanted to go to the United Kingdom illegally.
Duarte helped in out by helping him apply for asylum in France because that would be much safer. Together with co-writer Blandine Jet, Duarte decided to turn this real-life experience into a short film. An emotional short film that was created in very special ways.
First of all, the casting was a little bit unusual, especially for the leading character Adèle. Duarte tells us that he contacted the well-known French actress Marie Bunel ("Midnight Dreamers", "Accidental Family") via a Facebook message. To his surprise, she got back to him with the question to send her over the script. The rest is history!
According to Duarte himself, not a lot of famous French actors are still doing short movies and independent films so he found himself very lucky. Even more so because Bunel puts on a wonderful and immersive performance as the caring and worrying teacher who would do everything for her kids.
For the casting of the children, it was the regular casting. Seeing a lot of children of which some already acted and some didn't. Eventually, Duarte decided to go for an existing class to portray the school children in this film. For them, it felt like an adventure. Thanks to the fact that the children already knew each other gives this film a more authentic vibe. It could have been you and me when we were younger.
What an adventure it was! During our interview, Duarte told us that they made the ferry trip between France and England more than ten times. Filming on the ferry was difficult. Not only because of the size of it but also because eventually, people got seasick.
Despite those difficulties, the director would do it again in the same way and we can only approve that. It was all filmed in real life and there were no special effects visible in this short movie. Because of this approach, we get the feeling that we're on that boat and that we're part of the class.
After travelling around the world to promote his film, Duarte was very excited to screen it at the Raindance Film Festival on the 22nd of September 2019. If you didn't have the chance to catch it there, then we hope for you that "Harbor" will head to a film festival close to you because you need the opportunity to catch this wonderful, beautiful and emotional short film.
Still shaken up about what could have happened, Adèle and her children make their way to security. They see the same young boy again. This time, he's trying to fit into their class to get on the ferry. Adèle knows that if she takes the boy, who has no papers, on the ferry with them that this would be illegal. Her teacher's instinct rules over that thought and so she gets him on board.
It seems that the boy isn't talkative at all and so connecting with him is harder than Adèle thought it would be. While she's trying to do everything she can to get through to the boy, he's doing things he's not supposed to do. Going to places on the boat where he shouldn't be.
It all goes sideways during one night when he's caught by the security because he was on forbidden ground. What will happen to him and Adèle now that her actions are about to be revealed?
While there's no "based on real-life events" sign at the beginning of the film, this movie is partly based on reality. Director Duarte mentioned that when he was helping at the refugee camp in Calais, he met a young boy who wanted to go to the United Kingdom illegally.
Duarte helped in out by helping him apply for asylum in France because that would be much safer. Together with co-writer Blandine Jet, Duarte decided to turn this real-life experience into a short film. An emotional short film that was created in very special ways.
First of all, the casting was a little bit unusual, especially for the leading character Adèle. Duarte tells us that he contacted the well-known French actress Marie Bunel ("Midnight Dreamers", "Accidental Family") via a Facebook message. To his surprise, she got back to him with the question to send her over the script. The rest is history!
According to Duarte himself, not a lot of famous French actors are still doing short movies and independent films so he found himself very lucky. Even more so because Bunel puts on a wonderful and immersive performance as the caring and worrying teacher who would do everything for her kids.
For the casting of the children, it was the regular casting. Seeing a lot of children of which some already acted and some didn't. Eventually, Duarte decided to go for an existing class to portray the school children in this film. For them, it felt like an adventure. Thanks to the fact that the children already knew each other gives this film a more authentic vibe. It could have been you and me when we were younger.
What an adventure it was! During our interview, Duarte told us that they made the ferry trip between France and England more than ten times. Filming on the ferry was difficult. Not only because of the size of it but also because eventually, people got seasick.
Despite those difficulties, the director would do it again in the same way and we can only approve that. It was all filmed in real life and there were no special effects visible in this short movie. Because of this approach, we get the feeling that we're on that boat and that we're part of the class.
After travelling around the world to promote his film, Duarte was very excited to screen it at the Raindance Film Festival on the 22nd of September 2019. If you didn't have the chance to catch it there, then we hope for you that "Harbor" will head to a film festival close to you because you need the opportunity to catch this wonderful, beautiful and emotional short film.
Migrant story
searchanddestroy-116 February 2023
I should say ONE MORE migrant story. There are so many since one decade now, speaking of those tragedies occuring between Northern Africa or Middel East and Europe, or between France and Britan. It is so easy to speak, denounce this problem, this social drama. And it is also so tiring to watch again and again. Every knows that migrants problem is a tragedy, but too much is too much. That's my own opinion. Any screenwriter or director, even the worst one, can make something poignant, destined to make audiences weep. I am through with this kind of stuff. Sorry, folks. But this very one short film is well made, no problem. I would say flawless.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
