Before the Rain (1994) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
80 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Interesting - but why the middle section
MikeyB17931 February 2009
Warning: Spoilers
This is a 3 part film depicting events during the complex civil war in what use to be Yugoslavia. The first and third parts are set in the Balkans and for the most part are touching and authentic. A photographer returns to his homeland to witness the fracturing of it into war. This is well depicted in the movie - how communities that use to co-exist peacefully can somehow, through a tortured religious history,group pressure.. . gradually fracture into warring tribes. Another centerpiece of this story is a young girl forced to leave her village to try and save her life.

The second part is mostly disconnected from part 1 and 3. The English woman is pregnant and having marital problems, there is a mafia style shoot-up in a bar. It is entirely irrelevant to the themes presented in 1 and 3. Part 2 should have been edited to coalesce with 1 and 3. The only reason for the second installment is to provide a back-drop for the photographer to return, after a long absence, to his native land and witness the fissures developing. Also in part 2 we see photographs of the execution of the fleeing young woman,but at this stage the photographer was already dead!!
18 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A powerful look at the futility of hate
=G=30 July 2002
"Before the Rain" is a compelling drama which examines the ethnic hatreds bubbling over the cauldron of Macedonia in the wake of the post cold war Balkan fragmentation. A masterpiece of filmcrafting with a circular story backbone and a cosmopolitan cast, "BTR" focuses on one war weary Macedonian photo-journalist who returns to his roots to find his homeland torn by ethnic/religious hate. A must see for those into serious drama and foreign films. (A-)
9 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
You cannot understand before you see it [2]
wacd30 April 2000
This story marks the essence of what's happened in Balkans (former Yugoslavia) in past few years, and especially the circular plot of the movie is very significant. I was really shocked with certain moments of this film!

There's more lines in the plot - the story of native war photographer living in London, who wants to return to homeland - the movie itself starts with some kind of Romeo and Juliet war story - there's also a harsh killing scene in London restaurant, which is made by one of war radicals - very funny shot is that, when the UN inspection car stops at the hill far before the village, and after moment it returns back, while the village is guarded and divided by it's armed citizens - and maybe one missed telephone call could warn Alexander, who just returns to his birth village, and stop it all...

After some moments the lines of this more complex movie cut through and the circle of violence comes to its finale. But we're just on the beginning chronologically, so it seems everything is just starting again...
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Time is not a Circle, but War is
HanYan2 December 2001
A poignant tragedy about hatred, war, love and taking sides.

Time is not linear in the movie, but the director blatantly tells us that time is not a circle, so what is? The story is, and perhaps war is.

The story is told in three parts, with highly ironic titles: Words, Faces, and Pictures. Each story has meticulously planned, but highly disturbing parallels. The story-telling of the movie requires diligent planning, down to every single detail, exceptional creativity, and extraordinary persistence. Perhaps that's why the director Milcho Manchevski was fired by both commercial producers Warner Brothers and 20th Century Fox for "creative differences"

Before the Rain talks about hate, and how the power of hate can rise above love. It talks about taking sides, the central character in each section tries not to take sides, but circumstances often prove such efforts futile. As with Kiril and Aleksander.

In the film, all events happened before the rain, this sense of urgency, this beautiful sadness, and this inevitable tragedy. Before the Rain is my all time favourite movie.
68 out of 75 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Beautiful, tragic, stunning.
contronatura21 February 2000
The very structure of this film perfectly describes its philosophy - a never ending circle. And it's the structure that makes this film work so powerfully. From the shattering opening section, to the startling second part, to the third story that brings it all together, this is a great film. It's been overlooked for some reason, mentioned rarely in film magazines and in best of the decade lists. But it's a phenomenal work, one that needs to be seen.
76 out of 88 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Thank you Mr. Manchevski
GoranToo5 November 2004
This movie is absolute perfection. I can't believe it took me 10 years to bump into it by accident. I was surprised to see it was made in 1994 when the entire time I watched it as a reflection rather than prophecy of the civil war that followed.

The fluency of picture, music, and the story is perfect as viewer is taken from dramatic landscapes and slow paced life of orthodox priests to fast paced London streets and offices. Parallel stories in London fasten the pace even more.

The movie shows we are all connected not only in time (past and future) but space (geography) as well. War and suffering in one part of the world affect lives of people in quaint London restaurant. The circle of human tragedy connects almost every character in the movie. But circle is imperfect. If the circle were perfect the tragedy would stop when circle completes. Alas, the tragedy spirals in time and space.

Acting is very real. Time is not wasted overbuilding any character. The way soundtrack blends with the movie is pure art. Thank you for this movie Mr. Manchovski. As powerful as the movie is, it's unfortunate it didn't help prevent the civil war in Macedonia. When hate wins, innocence looses.
61 out of 71 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Thought provoking
occtipus21 January 2003
I was forced to watch this movie for a college class, and it instantly became one of my favorite movies of all time. The story is exceptional, and the directorial brilliance of its creators brings the tragedy of an entire country to life. It contrasts the folly of war and hatred with beautiful images of the people and places that they destroy.
26 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
One of the best movies I've ever seen
peter_olsson_111 September 2003
Beautiful, hard hitting, but still both simple and realistic. One of the most beautiful movies I've ever seen. I saw it the first time in 1997 I think and I've seen it at least twenty times so far and it grows bigger every time. I love this movie and can't give any bad comments about it. Some amy say there are some

beautiful scenes here and some ugly scenes there, but I love it just like it is and it's hard to change that.

Firs, the the acting is excellent and the main character Rade Serbedzija does a wonderful work as a cynical, down-to-earth photographer, who knows he can't

escape his destiny and identity, Katrin Cartlidge does an equally impressive job, as well as a lot o the Macedonian bad and good guys of the film.

Secondly, the cinematography wonderfully depicts the harsh Macedonian

landscapes and sceneries, as well as the torn souls of the land. The music has the same impact and feels so natural with the cinematography.

Finally, I could never complaint about the directors excellent work. This was his debut if I'm not wrong and that was very promising, but I suppose this was his "Citizen Kane" and it'll probably be impossible to make anything similar.

One rarely sees anything from Macedonia.But this is not only good for

Macedonian cinema, it should have won the Oscar that year.
61 out of 79 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Linear? circular? none and both?
Falkner197630 May 2022
Very interesting film about the tensions in Macedonia between Orthodox and Muslims. Structured in three parts, the second, which takes place in London, is necessary to give the conflict a more globalized scope, and contrast thematically and visually with the first and third, which take place in the rural world of Macedonia, but it is also the least achieved: it does not have a very close relationship with the rest, it establishes a sentimental plot of very minor interest, and it makes the main character a very topical one, easily extravagant and certainly unpleasant (the way of breaking up with the London girl is not very subtle, proposing her to come to live with him to his hometown, especially considering that there he is still in love with an Albanian woman). Still it has interesting scenes.

The first and third parts arte the important ones and have a certain symmetry: in this fight between two peoples, both parts culminate with a protagonist who dies at the hands of his own people.

The film shows the tensions that can lead a society to a civil war and how they are a vicious circle of reproaches, crimes and revenge, but at the same time advance in an escalation of violence that seems unstoppable. It is difficult to elucidate what came first and what came after, cause and consequence, who threw the first stone.

The structure is simpler than it seems, apparently a structure is proposed that could be linear or circular, but this is obviously not the case, and it is based on a certain trick that is not (and doesn't try) justified at the narrative level. For the structure to be linear and circular at the same time, we would have to ignore many details: those that make us read it as linear do not agree with those that make us read it as circular. No reading is fully valid from the narrative point of view.

As linear, Kiril in the first part says that he is going to see his photographer uncle in London ( but his uncle is already dead), the same uncle who stars in the second and third parts. In the second part, Anne observes some photographs of Zamira's corpse. This would take us to the linear chronology in which the first part is before the second and this second is before the third. But we realize that this cannot be so: we have seen the photographer's burial in the first part. And this forces us to read the second and third as flashbacks. And so it seems when we see that the events link with the prehistory of the first part... But that is impossible because in the second part Anne has seen the photos of Zamira's corpse.

It is impossible to determine which part comes before which. But this has been achieved in a very simple way: it would be enough to remove the detail of the photographs and Kiril's mention of going to see his photographer uncle and we would have a traditional film with a flashback that links to the beginning of the film. Obviously the filmmaker wants the viewer to see it in this second way and at the same time realise that something doesn't match and start thinking.

The photograph is very warm and saturated with color in its Macedonian part and cold and bluish in its London part. The film also gives us beautiful images of the landscapes, churches and villages of Macedonia.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Best Macedonian movie ever
perica-4315120 July 2018
This is a powerful movie about the circle of conflict, coming from the authentic Balkan region that is troubled by these issues for ages. It gives you the perspective on these themes in a great, artistic and sincere way. Highly recommended.
17 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Interestingly Formed Film
gavin694211 November 2015
The circularity of violence seen in a story that circles on itself. In Republic of Macedonia, during war in Bosnia, Christians hunt an ethnic Albanian girl who may have murdered one of their own. A young monk who's taken a vow of silence offers her protection.

First of all, you don't see many films from Macedonia. At least, I don't. I suppose people in Macedonia may see more. But that was the first thing that struck me. But more to the point, the film is interesting for its blend of cultures and languages, and its (possibly) unique plot device of three stories that could go in more or less any order.

I cannot say this was a film I truly loved, but it was one I admired. And it makes me wonder what else is out there from this same director or others involved. There is a whole world of film out there to be explored.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Really impressive, a mind-changing masterpiece
Adriano_Lessa20 November 2002
This movie is by far, the most touching movie i've ever seen. I think it impressed me just the same as "Merry Christmas Mr.Lawrence", though "Before the Rain" is a much more beautiful movie. It's a raw depicture of the Balkans conflict, but also a beautiful one. One with loads of violence but growing from this violence, there's love and compassion.The most touching movie i've ever seen.
15 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Good, but I would have preferred a more linear style
planktonrules24 April 2014
A recent trend in films is to present plots non-sequentially. This isn't done all the time, of course, but this radical way of constructing a plot have simply been overused in recent years. For me, the novelty has definitely worn off. Because of that, I wasn't as impressed with "Before the Rain" and many other reviewers.

This film consists of three stories--all which relate to Macedonia and ethnic violence. However, while at first the three stories only seem to have this as the common thread, some of the characters also appear in multiple stories--making one larger story about hatred and ethnic violence.

Story 1 is about an Albanian woman who is being sought by Christian Macedonians--and she's being sheltered by a monk who has taken a vow of silence.

Story 2 is about a pregnant Brit whose lover is Macedonian. He has been living abroad for many years but leaves to go back--and leaves her behind pregnant. When she meets her husband to ask for a divorce, BAD things happen somewhat out of the blue.

Story 3 shows the man in 2 in Macedonia and his return isn't as happy as he'd hoped.

Each story is well done and interesting. The acting and direction are also quite nice. But as I indicated above, I am personally tiring of non-sequential films and the novelty has worn off for me. Well done but I am not in love with the film.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Timeline Was Too Dischordant
anthony_retford9 November 2009
Warning: Spoilers
Obviously most people are enthralled with this movie. I wasn't. The music was good but the cinematography was lacking - too many shots shown over again. I watch a lot of foreign movies and, I guess, unfortunately had just watched "A Very Long Engagement" with cinematography that excelled. I suppose the message in Before The Rain was that time may not have been circular but it certainly comes back onto itself. The feeling I had was that the writer wanted to paint this little universe, which always repeated itself. Was this plot anything to do with the reality we all live in? No! We live in a linear reality and we don't see pictures of things that haven't happened yet. I thought it was more than depressing that the cycle the writer chose was punctuated with fusillades of gunfire from start to end. I thought "Dark Country" made better use of an enclosed circular universe.

I also found the likelihood that someone could return to his old home after 16 years false, especially with the tribality and backwardness of the inhabitants which he had outgrown shortly after leaving. I have been traveling for 7 years and things are different. I could not go back to what was and be a part of those I knew. So the idea that Rade, world-wise traveler thought he could just enter his old stomping grounds did not make sense. He would have had more sense, particularly when he was met by a gun-toting guard. When he first arrived he saw his house had been abandoned so how could he not understand his old life had also been abandoned?
9 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
unforgettable and illuminating
gookie7 May 1999
i saw this film last year and for the rest of the day could not shake the emotional response it had provoked within me. totally original in its construction, it makes the "inventive" timelines of tarantino's work look childish and simplistic. this film tells so many stories and helped me understand the balkan conflict in a new light-- i can't reccomend it highly enough. one of the greatest in recent memory. absolutely beautiful photography. repeat viewings don't diminish its impact-- a rare achievement, especially for a film that is built on what could have easily been a formal 'gimmick'-- but the semi-cyclic form serves the film and heightens the impact and the meaning.
31 out of 41 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Perfect Definition & Explanation of the Macedonian Problem
viktor8311 February 2004
This film by Milcho Manchevski is the ideal when talking about explaining and defining the Macedonian problem. I am Macedonian but I live in Germany. So I think I have an overview so that I am able to criticize. The problem between the ethnic groups in Macedonia go around in circles. But in the end it turns out that the circle goes round like a ferry wheel. Everything is happening again and again. The circle is not round though. In every end there is a change. A change which always makes the new beginning worse. In a way it is like a spiral. And Manchevski is smartly telling three stories. They are not linear, but in a way they come close to what the problem really is like. With the last episode he connects the three stories, and you can feel the message - his message.

Unfortunately this film was quite popular only in Europe and I think even in the US, but in Macedonia it was rarely seen by the people. I think if every single Macedonian Citizen had seen and understood this movie, it would be much easier to solve the Macedonian problem today. Because what it says is that we ourselves kill each other. Because of hatred and ethnic principles we force ourselves to fight against each other. And that is exactly why it is leading to nowhere. Because it is a circle...and the circle is not round. And one day, when the spiral is at its end, it's going to be too late.
40 out of 55 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
masterful plot and execution
beatnik-410 May 1999
This for my money is one of the best films of the last ten years. The plot does a wonderful job of starting and ending in the same place, a device Pulp Fiction stole and did less well. Essential for anyone who wants to understand the conflict between Orthodox and Muslim cultures in the Balkans and anyone who simply enjoys a finely crafted film.
18 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Masterpiece
igor_jas18 October 2014
Warning: Spoilers
The movie has it all, amassing storyline with lots of great metaphors (even the title is a metaphor for forthcoming turmoil), great acting, beautiful music and colorful picture. The main storyline happens in Macedonia, but the movie is timeless and it is true for every conflict in the world, as in the movie the director in a beautiful way plays with time and places. Take any conflict in the world and you will see the same, how the violence can bring more hatred, turmoil and nothing good, and how hard can be to break this circle. But as it says in the movie the circle is not always round, it is not everything as it seems, and this circle of violence can be hardly broken. Truly a Masterpiece, and it won't be exaggerated if I say this is a movie version of Picasso's Guernica. The shapes are not easy to see, but when you see it you will understand it is stunning and it carries beautiful message.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Great !!!
18007 January 2001
This is the best movie i have ever seen. I really love it. Although it was shot in 1994, this movie is still very actual in present. It tells much about mentality of people in former Yugoslavia. It has my best recommendation. If u have a chance 2 c it, don't miss it. Jan Zajic
6 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Beautiful Cinematography
boblipton6 June 2023
In three linked stories,a young couple in North Macedonia is torn apart because they are from different ethnic groups; a North Macedonian war photographer in London sees his pregnant girlfriend-agent shot; and he returns to his home village to become involved in the internecine violence between the same ethnic groups as in the first part.

I'm certainly no expert in North Macedonian cinema, but the photography in that country is beautiful; it looks little changed in the ninety years between the Manaki brothers' first movies and 1994 -- hardly surprising in a land settled perhaps five thousand years ago. What's a century, more or less.

The point is, of course, the pointlessness of the hatred that inspires all this bloodshed. The camerawork, the theme, and the fact that it seems to have been the first movie released in North Macedonia after that country gained its independence were enough to gain it an Academy Award nomination for Best Foreign Language Picture.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Masterpiece of Masterpieces
malatzky15 December 1999
Like Yol, we have here a film that brings you into the way of life of a People, living in the mountains and outside of the modern world and you know that ethnic rivalries are bred here. The males go around carrying uzis and the Albanians and Macedonians just can't wait to kill each other. Beautiful photography and music. A different world, there in the Balkans!
6 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Powerful Movie
musicalpenguin219 September 2005
Warning: Spoilers
This movie is incredibly powerful. For anyone who has studied Eastern European history this movie brings the Muslim-Christian relations and tensions into reality. WARNING: If you like movies to neatly tie up all loose ends by the the end, this movie is not for you! Just as the quote says, "Time never dies: The circle is not round," the movie leaves you with a lot of confusion and questions about the plot, but the message is no less incredible. If you like history then this movie is for you. I watched it for the first time in 10th grade in my AP European History class and it made an incredible impact on the way I thought about religious relations in Eastern Europe and the Middle East.

Awesome movie that I highly recommend!
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
before the rain
mossgrymk17 June 2023
Never made it to London and section two. Was waylaid in Macedonia and held at stupefying gunpoint by that veteran European bandit, Art H Boredom.

Truly, Barnum could take lessons in suckerdom from Milcho Manchevzski. Don't know exactly what this dull director's thought processes were exactly, but I imagine they went something like this: "Let's see. I'll take a serious subject and treat it VERY seriously. That means no humor, of course, and lots of irrelevantly gorgeous cinematography. Then I'll throw in Gregorian chants and monks to let the viewer know that this is sensitive, profound stuff they're watching, and just in case they don't get the message I'll make the pacing REAL slow and the silences between speakers super long. That should earn me at least honorable mention at Cannes." Solid C.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
From Macedonia With Love
elihu-21 February 2000
The wars in former Yugoslavia have resounded in every corner of that region, and have ignited all manner of subsequent ethnic and religious conflicts within the newly-formed republics. Focusing world attention upon the region through the media has occasionally had the positive effect of raising awareness of the conflicts through art. The work of artists from former Yugoslavia has found an appreciation that has never really existed before, partly due to the fact that they are the most fit to interpret the events there. The republic of Macedonia is certainly experiencing its share of strife.

Nestled in between the countries of Serbia, Bulgaria, Greece, and Albania, it is surrounded by strained relations on all sides, countries that have refused to recognize its autonomy for a long time. A significant Albanian Moslem minority feuds with the dominant Orthodox Christian Slav population. Hardly a week passes without a new arms network running from Alabania to Macedonia being discovered. Despite the presence of U.N. peacekeeping forces, armed skirmishes ravage the countryside.

Milcho Manchevski left his native Macedonia to pursue a college education in the U.S. He studied film at Southern Illinois University. Upon graduating, he moved to New York and began working on commercial, experimental films, and music videos. BEFORE THE RAIN is his first full-length feature, for which he returned to his native country to make. He was able to secure British and French financing with his creative, authoritative and topical screenplay. An inspiring tale about the senselessness of war and the fragility of humans and their loves, the film is, despite some minute flaws, one of the most passionate and sublime cinematic statements of the '90s.

It has an intriguing, if not wholly original non-linear narrative structure. Through three episodes titled, "Words," "Faces," and "Pictures," respectively, the viewer is introduced to three characters whose lives interconnect from minute to strongly significant ways.

Kiril (Gregoire Collin, of OLIVIER, OLIVIER) is a young novice in an Orthodox monastery who cannot help but hide Zamira (Labina Mitevska), a fugitive Albanian girl, from the villagers who want to execute her for murdering a shepherd. He does it out of the goodness of his heart, but perhaps also out of the beginnings of a lustful affection for her. They flee north in an attempt to find Kiril's uncle in Skopje, and meet with dire hardship and tragedy.

Meanwhile, in England, Anne (Katrin Kartlidge, most familiar as the lisping goth girl from Mike Leigh's film NAKED), a photo editor is in the midst of a personal crisis. She is becoming more and more disaffected with her husband Nick (Jay Villiers) while experiencing a difficult, confused relationship with her lover, Aleksandar (Rade Serbedzija), an award-winning native Macedonian photographer. Unsure of what to do, she distances herself from both men, but cannot stem the tide of the turbulent events all around her. The story dispenses with her husband in somewhat contrived way, and she ends up trying to find Aleksandar, who has since left for Macedonia.

Aleksandar returns to his native village, only to find that the overall climate has radically changed, and the simple life he tries to rediscover has since been made more complex by the feuds with the Albanians. His return is met with mixed reactions from warm welcomes from his close friends, to cold-shouldering by the newly-armed local anti-Albanian faction, to outright hatred from some of the Albanians. When his childhood love from a neighboring village seeks his aid to help protect her daughter, Aleksandar is thrust into the heart of the conflict, and his refusal to takes sides has tragic repercussions.

Serbedzija interprets the role with a noble, morally centered sense of confidence. One of former Yugoslavia's most well known and respected actors Serbedzija found his role to be a way of protesting the conflicts in his region-"As an artist, as someone well-known, I had to speak out against nationalism and war. As Aleksandar was presumed to take sides, so was I. It's my story. What ends up happening to Aleksandar, when cousins take arms against cousins, has happened to many in former Yugoslavia and it could happen to me."

With its non-linear structure, the time-line of the film is somewhat incoherent, and there are some plot developments in the middle segment, occurring in England, which are a bit too pat. These are balanced by the striking, somewhat exotic visuals and original, exhilarating neo-ethnic music by a group called Anastasia, fine acting (especially by Collin and Serbedzija), and an overall poignant sense of the waste of war, even a war in its beginnings.

Manchevski illuminates his use of the film's title-"There was this sense of something heavy beginning to happen, something looming in the air. At the same time life was continuing as before. This story doesn't deal with the political aspects of how wars start. It's about human passion and how it can lead one in different, unexpected directions. It's about how a war somewhere in the world might get started and how that can affect your life regardless of where you are. Ultimately, it's about taking sides."
25 out of 35 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Time never dies, the circle is not round.
stodruza20 March 2009
Warning: Spoilers
But this film's construction is, like the cycle of war. Brilliant, as of course is the film. Gotta do ten lines.

This is one of the best anti-war films ever made, on par with Bardov's Prisoner of the Mountains, which I recommend to you, along side Susan Beir's Brothers.

Should be required viewing for all politicians...The art in this film is immense, from the film stock, to the lighting, acting, story, in essence, a perfect film. Have to wonder about people who don't appreciate it, much less enjoy it on some level. Brutally honest film about the consequences of war.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed